- From: Kevin Jenkins <kj@iteegosearch.com>
- Date: Thu, 9 Jul 2009 23:54:42 -0700
- To: <semantic-web@w3.org>
- Message-ID: <007101ca012b$4e4b4e20$eae1ea60$@com>
Greetings, I sent an e-mail previously inquiring about naming conventions. In retrospect, I can see my question didn’t make much sense. I have since been working extensively with the protégé 4 Owl Editor and have learned much in the way of answering my own questions. However, I am still running into an issue with naming conventions, but I do have a better understanding now of what exactly it is that I’m trying to get advice for. I am currently trying to create an ontology for software. As you can imagine, software is a very complex product and there is a lot to it. After weeks I believe I have arrived at a smart and intuitive class and subclass structure. The problem I’m having now is how to name my classes and subclasses. My structure is 5 levels deep where level 1 is the root class and level 5 is the individual (or instance). Naming classes and instances after level 1 is perplexing. I was hoping somebody here could give me some advice on how this might be done using current ontology best practices. Below I am including a small example of the current structure below. I have not tried to officially name the classes yet as I’m not sure how. So I have used a temporary naming convention that enables me to easily understand and organize my classes. But I am getting to the point now where I’d like to start officially naming them. ========= Product (Root Class) --- software ------ desktop software ------------ desktop internet software ------------------- desktop internet access software (individual) ------------------- desktop internet browser software (individual) ------------------- desktop internet messaging software (individual) ------------ desktop multimedia software ------------------- desktop multimedia 3d software (individual) ------------------- desktop multimedia audio software (individual) ------------------- desktop multimedia video software (individual) ------ internet software ------------ internet saas software ------------------- internet saas collaboration software (individual) ------------------- internet saas videosharing software (individual) ------------ internet cloud software ------ enterprise software Person (Root Class) Press (Root Class) ========= It is my understanding all names must be unique (at least that seems to be what the protégé editor is saying). I should probably be using some combination of suffix and prefix to ensure so. But which ones? Also, I understand that shorter names are preferred. As you can see, by the time I get down to the instance level the name gets very long if I am to keep it unique and human understandable. Of course I could use a lot of acronym type names which would be short and sweet for machines, but entirely unintelligible for humans. I would really appreciate some advice on how to intelligently name my class structure. Obviously, I’m most concerned with Levels 3-5. Levels 1-2 are basic. I hope this time I have made much more sense with my inquiry. Thanks for the help! Regards Kevin
Received on Friday, 10 July 2009 06:55:26 UTC