Minutes XSLT WG Telcon 17 December 2015

>7.0 Pending - from Joint Meeting
>
>   J4.7.1 Bug 29146 - [FO31] fn:transform options update
>https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=29146
>   status?

Proposal brought to the joint meeting and approved.

Bug is closed.

>8.0 Spec bugs since entering CR - first bug #29234
>
>29234  [xslt30ts] package-908  Discuss

There is no static error, but there should almost always be a dynamic
error and error XTDE0045 will be modified to make this clear.

Decided to accept comment 3 together with the following addition from
Abel:
A Note of some sort to emphasize that an empty *principal*
package cannot be invoked directly, unless as a library package.
Possibly adding that the cause of this is that the default mode is the
empty mode which is not declared, but must be declared by default.

ACTION 2015-12-17-002: Mike Kay to carry out the decisions made for
resolving
bug 29234.

>29256  accept-041c - error XTSE3080    Discuss

The testcase does now specify "absent" for C:f1 in the xsl:accept
and thus there is no error any more.

Unclear, however, (from bug description):
Note that XTSE3080 suggests it's only an error if there is a reference to
the abstract component, whereas the statement in 3.5.3.3 suggests it's
an error whether or not the component is referenced.

MSMQ would prefer being "draconian".

This could be quite workable with some "tweaking" for specifying
wildcards.

MSMQ is changing his mind...

We clearly need to think about this and come back at the next telcon.