- From: Jean-Claude MARTIN <martin@limsi.fr>
- Date: Sat, 10 Feb 2007 11:22:48 +0100
- To: EMOXG-public <public-xg-emotion@w3.org>
- CC: Marc Schroeder <schroed@dfki.de>
Dear all, Please find below two general comments. I did not include them in the wiki page as I did not find a relevant single place where to put them. Best regards, Jean-Claude -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- WHICH COMPONENTS OF EMOTION SHOULD BE COVERED BY THE REPRESENTATION LANGUAGE We might want to state clearly the components of emotions that are to be covered by the language (eg in (Scherer 00): physiological arousal, motor expression, action tendencies and subjective feeling). For example, should the language enable to represent action tendencies? Where is annotated the fact that a given representation of an emotion is the representation of a subjective feeling? We might annotate the component(s) of the emotion that is (are) annotated in the section on "Emotion Core". SHOW IN USE CASES HOW THE LANGUAGE ENABLES TO COVER DIFFERENT THEORETICAL APPROACHES In order to show the coverage of the language, we should put as a requirement that it should enable to represent emotion according to different models: categorial, dimensional, appraisal, OCC, PAD... The use cases so far have focused on applications (annotation, detection and generation) rather than covering different theoretical approaches and models. When reconsidering the use cases (once we have improved the definition of the language), we might want to take a single example and describe different representations of this example according to different models (and not a single whole representation of the example which would be to complex and not readable). We should also use the language to describe examples that focus on one section of the requirements : mixed emotions, regulation, ... Would it be relevant to point or include in the use case document a link to publicly available video/animation clips (e.g. from the pilot database or others) described in the examples ? --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Received on Saturday, 10 February 2007 10:22:57 UTC