RE: ISSUE-101 Create "visiting known site that is now malware" use case as per ACTION-275

This use case is now at:
 
http://www.w3.org/2006/WSC/drafts/note/#any-iio-1
 
It doesn't fit into our current categorization of
Believing/Providing/Installing, since there is no user interaction, so
I've just marked it "No interaction" and left it out of the category
table.
 
--Tyler


________________________________

	From: public-wsc-wg-request@w3.org
[mailto:public-wsc-wg-request@w3.org] On Behalf Of Mary Ellen Zurko
	Sent: Friday, September 28, 2007 8:49 AM
	To: public-wsc-wg@w3.org
	Subject: ISSUE-101 Create "visiting known site that is now
malware" use case as per ACTION-275
	
	

	After much discussion, and great work on the part of all
participants to craft the most acceptable proposal, we are resolving
this issue according to the results of the poll. 
	
	The final proposal for the use case is: 
	
	Betty tries to connect to a web site at
<http://www.example.com/>. <http://www.example.com/%3E.> She visits this
site frequently to read various news and articles. Since her last visit,
the site example.com has been compromised by some method, and visitors
are now being infected with malware. At the time of the current request,
Betty's user agent now has information saying that example.com is a
known bad site. What interaction, if any, should occur?
	
	The poll results are: 
	
	Accept: 7 
	(ian f, anil s, thomas r, johnathan n, dan s, audian p, phill
h-b)
	
	Abstain: 3
	(jan vidar k, cristian s, rachna d)
	
	Against:: 2
	(tyler c, serge e)
	
	
	Absent a material error in the count, I declare concensus on
this issue. The editors will add the use case to wsc-usecases, and add
Ian Fette to acknowlegements. 
	
	
	On a related note, I am sorry I was not around to give direct
feedback to people when the discussion tone occasionally slipped out of
the totally professional and respectful. I know everyone is capable of
engaged and even handed discussion, even when they totally disagree with
others, and that an occasional personal and private reminder can go a
long way towards halting any slips that might occur.