Misc Comments - Part 2

1). What additional interop does test1204 test for other than that 
tested by test1202 and test1203 ?

2). In test1205, if FaultTo address is "none" then no fault message 
should be sent back. Moreover the message from A to B is a one-way 
message, so even by that there should be no response sent back. I think 
SOAP12-HTTP-In-Only-Fault does not fit here unless I'm missing something 
  obvious.

Further, I'm trying to understand what WS-A feature interop is this 
testcase testing ?

4). There is no test for "Action Not Supported" fault. I thought at one 
time we agreed that is the most common fault scenario (cant find 
reference though). On a related point, I think test1240 should instead 
be checking for "Action Not Supported" fault since that is more likely 
to occur. A duplicate To or any other WS-A header in the SOAP message is 
less likely to occur.

5). test1133: Test description does not mention about ReplyTo containing 
reference parameters but even then there is an XPath check. I think the 
XPath check is correct as it will ensure that even though both ReplyTo 
and FaultTo has reference parameters, only FaultTo refps are returned. 
Further, the test description should be updated to reflect that.

5). What interop feature is 1206 testing ?

6). In test 1207, is the inconsistency between the number reference 
parameters and metadata intentional ? I think we should try to keep the 
test simple and just one of each (I dont care which one we choose).

7). I thought the purpose of test1208 is to test all possible 
extensiblity points. But no EPR extensiblity attributes are used ? For 
example in the related message [1],

<wsa:ReplyTo>

could be replaced with

<wsa:ReplyTo extraMetadata="true">.

Similarly, there are no extensiblity attributes on wsa:Address. For example,

<wsa:Address>

could be replaced with

<wsa:Address physical="true">

[1] 
http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/addr/testsuite/documents/notify/soap12/message9.xml

Thanks,
-Arun

-- 
got Web Services ?
Download Java Web Services Developer Pack from
http://java.sun.com/webservices

Received on Tuesday, 20 December 2005 10:44:12 UTC