W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > whatwg@whatwg.org > June 2009

[whatwg] Proposal: JavaScript stack traces

From: Jordan Osete <jor@joozt.net>
Date: Fri, 12 Jun 2009 11:05:48 +0200
Message-ID: <4A321A6C.3040204@joozt.net>
Hi.

I've wondered for some time if it weren't possible to harmonize stack
traces across browsers.

* What is the problem you are trying to solve? *
If you want a traceback, you need to cater for multiple browsers
behaviours, and different and incomplete information.

* What is the feature you are suggesting to help solve it? *
Harmonize JavaScript stack traces across browsers. There could be a
global getStackTrace() method, wich would return an array of stack
frames, closest one first (or last, I don't care). Every stack frame
object could have the following properties:

To identify what script we are in:
- the script filename, if external script (JSFileName)
- or HTML filename, in case of an inline script (HTMLFileName)
- or, in case of an "eval()" call, a special evalScope property must be
set to true
- a reference to the script tag DOM object, if the script was not eval'd
(scriptTag)

To identify where in the script we are:
- a simple way to get the script's full source code, whatever way it is
eval'd or included. For example, a fullJSSourceCode property
- the line number, relative to the start of the script (sourceLine)
- the line number, relative to the start of the file containing the
script. It is equal to sourceLine, except if it is an inline script in
an HTML file (fileLine)
- the position of the substring delimiting the instruction in the source
code, relative to the start of the line. This is especially useful if
the JS source is "packed" or minifed, and thus newlines have been
suppressed (instructionOffsetStart and instructionOffsetEnd)

And about the environment:
- a reference to the "this" object in the given stack frame (thisObj)
- a reference to the function called (func). This is a function object.
- the arguments the function was called with, just like the arguments
pseudo-array in a function (arguments)
- a reference to the variable object, that carries all of the variables
that have been defined with the "var" statement, and that can be
accessed in this stack frame ? (variables)

Also, exception objects that are thrown by the browser could by default
have a stackTrace property. Please note that if the stack trace is
obtained with getStackTrace, the closest stack frame object would always
be the call to the getStackTrace() function. Thus it could easily be
discarded if needed ( if( stackTrace[ 0 ].func == window.getStackTrace )
stackTrace.shift(); ).

* Why do you think browsers would implement this feature? *

Many browsers already provide a facility for debugging, each giving
different informations. See for example:
https://developer.mozilla.org/En/Core_JavaScript_1.5_Reference/Global_Objects/Error/Stack
It wouldn't be too hard to standardize that.
The only potential problem I can see is keeping the references to the
variables, arguments, and this object. It would be nice to have
implementors' feedback on this.

* Why do you think authors would use this feature? *

See for example this page, it's an attempt to provide a stack trace in
every browser: http://eriwen.com/javascript/js-stack-trace/

* What evidence is there that this feature is desparately needed? *

It would help every JS programmer out there in JS debugging, and also
libraries for unit testing, etc.

Jordan OSETE
Received on Friday, 12 June 2009 02:05:48 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Wednesday, 22 January 2020 16:59:13 UTC