Re: WOFF2 spec and CTS updates

As far as the spec is concerned, we can declare it done as soon as we agree no other changes are needed. The CTS tests can be done any moment now, and when both things are done - all we need to wait for is to have two independent implementations passing all tests.

The toasting business, on the other hand, can be started at any moment right now - no need to wait for anything to be done since the very first toast could be for "all this to be done soon" and we can progress from there :)

Thank you,
Vlad


On Oct 5, 2015, at 8:25 PM, Roderick Sheeter <rsheeter@google.com<mailto:rsheeter@google.com>> wrote:


And when can we declare done and have a toast or 8?

On Mon, Oct 5, 2015, 5:07 PM Chris Lilley <chris@w3.org<mailto:chris@w3.org>> wrote:
Hello Vlad,

Monday, October 5, 2015, 11:10:09 PM, you wrote:

> In preparation for the discussions at our telcon on Wednesday and
> upcoming F2F next week I made the following changes:
>
> - WOFF2 spec - added a new UA conformance requirement in the end of
> the section 4.2 "Collection directory format" [1] and its
> description in UA test plan [2] to address open action 184;

> - Updated the language of the hmtx transform to disallow null
> transform [3];

> - Added new test cases [4-7] covering new conformance requirements
> for 'hmtx' table transform;

These look great.

Vlad, I made a few small editorial updates after your changes:

- split the changes appendix into two, firstly the changes from FPWD
to the latest published draft on /TR, and secondly the changes to the
ED since the last /TR publication. This will help reviewers (and is
needed for the next /TR publication)
- updated the Brotli reference to draft-06 (it was draft-02, although
the link given took you to the latest in any case).

> At this point, I think that we at least have full CTS coverage as
> far as test plans vs. spec are concerned and should be able to
> finalize all the descriptions and update the status of the existing
> tests at the F2F.

Agreed.


--
Best regards,
 Chris  Lilley
 Technical Director, W3C Interaction Domain