- From: Arthur Barstow <art.barstow@nokia.com>
- Date: Fri, 05 Oct 2012 14:59:07 -0400
- To: ext Rick Byers <rbyers@google.com>
- CC: public-webevents@w3.org
On 10/1/12 9:28 PM, ext Rick Byers wrote: > With the following two changes, and Art's guidance that these tests > should focus on testing the spec, not interoperability between > implementations, I'm now happy with the state of single-touch.html > > On the multiple test results for the same problem issue, how about a > simple pragmatic trade-off: collapse all failures about > identifiedTouch into one. This addresses my main use case (wanting to > be able to glance at the failures and make sure they're all > understood) without adding much complexity. I've committed a proposed > change for that here: > https://github.com/AFBarstow/WebEvents/commit/eef7fbdb9e08bc5c901d0678d2f7ae35b35f7071. > Seem OK? Your two changes look OK to me so I copied the latest file on GH to Hg and put it in a new dir called Moz-Nok-Goog since it has contributions from Matt, Rick and Art: <http://w3c-test.org/webevents/tests/touch-events-v1/submissions/Moz-Nok-Goog/single-touch.html> I would appreciate it folks would please run this version and report results. On my Nokia N9 I got 233 Passes and 3 Fails: * 2 are Expected: "document.createTouchList exists and correctly creates a TouchList from a single Touch" ; Actual: "assert_equals: touchList.length is 1, expected 1 bug 0" ; * 1 Expected: "TouchList contans an identifiedTouch property" ; Actual: "assert_true: expected tru got false" ; [I think this is a browser bug that was reported earlier] Re multi-touch testing, next week I hope to take a deep dive but if someone can beat me to it, that would be very much appreciated! -Thanks, Art > And for the screenX/Y failures on mobile devices: given the above and > the complexity of the various scale factors applied in different > scenarios (browser zoom, vs. device scale, etc), I don't think it's > worth trying to validate these values. I've removed them: > https://github.com/AFBarstow/WebEvents/commit/86d50fc931a97f408234e937c4d45d3fbb03ff6d > > Rick
Received on Friday, 5 October 2012 18:59:30 UTC