Re: RfC: LCWD of Custom Elements; deadline November 21

On 12/3/13 11:46 PM, ext Dimitri Glazkov wrote:
> I don't have any objections to waiting for the folks to catch up. 
> We'll just keep it in LC until next year.

Given the feedback on this thread, I don't think we have broad consensus 
to move  Custom Elements to CR so I support Dimitri's proposal.

Jonas, Ryosuke - if you haven't already done so, please file related 
bugs so we can track the issues you see with this spec (as well as any 
of the other Web Components spec).

-Thanks, ArtB

> :DG<
> On Tue, Dec 3, 2013 at 5:52 PM, Ryosuke Niwa < 
> <>> wrote:
>     We share the same concern Jonas raised here.
>     In addition, we had been postponing reviewing the Web Components
>     specifications
>     due to the "heavy" refactoring of the Shadow DOM specification
>     announced in July:
>     Now we know that there has been an effort to decouple the various
>     Web Components
>     features and specifications, and the Custom Elements specification
>     was going to
>     the Last Call on its own.
>     Unfortunately, we didn't know about this until fairly recently,
>     which is why our
>     thorough review of these specifications did not happen until
>     mid-September
>     (by which time this spec had already reached the Last Call).
>     We worked really hard to write up our feedback on the cross-origin
>     use case before
>     the Last Call deadline so that our feedback could be addressed
>     before the spec hits CR.
>     We still don't feel that moving the Custom Elements specification
>     into CR now, on its own,
>     is a good idea given that many of the most important use cases for
>     Custom Elements
>     naturally involve features in other Web Components specifications,
>     such as Shadow DOM.
>     - R. Niwa
>     On Dec 3, 2013, at 11:29 AM, Jonas Sicking <
>     <>> wrote:
>>     I don't know how Apple feels, but I still don't feel like we at
>>     Mozilla has had the ability to do a thorough enough review of the
>>     spec
>>     to say that it's ready for CR. I believe both Mozilla and Apple
>>     raised
>>     this concern when we went into LC.
>>     / Jonas

Received on Wednesday, 4 December 2013 12:10:19 UTC