Re: Installing web apps

On 2012-02 -01, at 15:23, Marcos Caceres wrote:

> Hi Tim,  
> 
> On Wednesday, 1 February 2012 at 16:42, Tim Berners-Lee wrote:
> 
>> Note that when people talk about installation, they often immediately discuss
>> packaging and manifest formats, which will need to be defined,
> 
> Umů we have a REC for that, remember?  

Yes, but I'm specifically trying to avoid the discussion of whether you use
widgets or manifests or node.js or what.

Sorry, we have come a long way from my original comment on public-webaps about 
the same-origin-policy needing a way of letting a script know why the 
access failed, which lead to Ian H saying that here was no need
for installation and my saying that there was.  So I was arguing for the need
for installation, and I am if course aware of widgets.

I precisely *didn't* want to get into a detail about whether everyone should use
widgets or will use widgets -- I want to argue for XMLHTTPRequest 
being designed to be able to be used not only in an untrusted web page,
but e.g. from an installed widget, or node.js for that matter,
which means returning a defined error response when the privilege is
insufficient, instead of faking a network error.
I've been trying to write code which will work in any of these.


Tim

Received on Wednesday, 1 February 2012 21:04:08 UTC