Re: [voiceinteraction] minutes October 9, 2024

Thank you, Debbie.

Here is the link to the presentation: 
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/13ONyFA96wsWqnEV3jCTvHl6ze7rCspjZuhZ9bU66U50/edit?usp=sharing

Dirk

On 09/10/2024 19:13, Deborah Dahl wrote:
> https://www.w3.org/2024/10/09-voiceinteraction-minutes.html
> and below as text
> Note that the next call will be in two weeks, October 23.
>     [1]W3C
>
>        [1] https://www.w3.org/
>
>                               - DRAFT -
>                             Voice Interaction
>
> 09 October 2024
>
>     [2]IRC log.
>
>        [2] https://www.w3.org/2024/10/09-voiceinteraction-irc
>
> Attendees
>
>     Present
>            debbie, dirk, gerard
>
>     Regrets
>            -
>
>     Chair
>            debbie
>
>     Scribe
>            ddahl
>
> Contents
>
>      1. [3]Summary of action items
>
> Meeting minutes
>
>     dirk: Robin's paper should help us figure out which kinds of
>     assistants exist
>
>     Value Co-creation in smart services: a functional affordances
>     perspective
>
>     (Dirk's presentation will be posted to the mailing list)
>
>     dirk: smart personal assistant doesn't need to be personal
>     . there is not an agreeded upon term
>     . material properties are important, there's a taxonomy in the
>     paper
>
>     debbie: not sure how a robot would it into the hardware slot
>
>     gerard: how does the sharing of your personal data with a cloud
>     provider fit into this?
>
>     dirk: handling of personal data doesn't fit, but that's the
>     only thing I can think of
>
>     could add a row for data sharing
>
>     dirk: don't share, share encrypted to trusted parties, or share
>     completely
>
>     dirk: vectorized the SPA's and clustered them
>     . reviews the clusters
>     . five clusters, passive observers, chatbots, virtual
>     anthropomorphic advisors
>     . cluster 3 is the most common
>     . 4th cluster is voice facilitators
>     . can also control objects in a smart home
>     . cluster 6 is general activity assistants, like Alexa
>
>     dirk: the interesting part is the 5 clusters
>
>     dirk: what is the difference between voice facilitators and
>     general activity assistants
>     . perhaps adaptability
>     . also voice facilitators are bound to a domain
>
>     dirk: we should acknowledge that there are different kinds of
>     agents and refer to them in our papers
>
>     debbie: we could eliminate some clusters
>
>     dirk: chatbots
>
>     debbie: cluster 2, 3
>
>     gerard: a personal assistant should not be shared with other
>     users
>
>     dirk: also in-scope are clusters 4 and 5
>
>     debbie: we have to think of more user-friendly names
>     . maybe cluster 4 and cluster 5 could have the same name
>
>     debbie: our standards could apply to several clusters
>
>     dirk: we should think about that
>
>     debbie: we need to capture the personal/general assistant
>     distinguished
>
>     gerard: a personal assistant should not be shared
>
>     dirk: two meanings of personal, one belongs to the user, also
>     the personal assistant could adapt but the data could be shared
>     . personal means that it knows the user
>     . and it knows how the user acts
>
>     dirk: this can cause some confusion
>
>     dirk: user-adaptive means the ability to adapt to the user
>
>     dirk: data shared outside the device
>
>     debbie: they could add the row and recluster
>
>     ACTION: dirk to respond to Robin's about the discussion today
>
>     debbie: they could also include LLMs
>
> Summary of action items
>
>      1. [4]dirk to respond to Robin's about the discussion today
>
>
>
>
>

Received on Thursday, 10 October 2024 16:47:59 UTC