Minutes of Silver TF teleconference of 3 November 2017

Formatted minutes of meeting:

https://www.w3.org/2017/11/03-silver-minutes.html


Text of minutes:

[1]W3C

       [1] http://www.w3.org/


                     Silver Task Force Teleconference

03 Nov 2017

Attendees

    Present
           MichaelC, JanMcSorley, Jemma, jeanne, Josie, Michael,
           Jennison

    Regrets
           Shawn, Sharri

    Chair
           jeanne

    Scribe
           Jan

Contents

      * [2]Topics
          1. [3]NcNally Survey Analysis
          2. [4]Tyson survey questions
          3. [5]Pete McNally Survey Analysis
      * [6]Summary of Action Items
      * [7]Summary of Resolutions
      __________________________________________________________

NcNally Survey Analysis

Tyson survey questions

    [8]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOauw
    9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y

       [8] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOauw9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y

    <jeanne> jeanne: The questions are directly from our research
    questions and seem like the language is too technical for a
    survey. I doubt that teachers would want to answer it.

    <jeanne> Ryan: They should make it more personal. Like "what
    tools do you use to evaluate accessibility?"

    <jeanne> Jan: I think most teachers will not know who the W3C
    is. I think Tyson is targeting Computer Science majors and
    teachers, but I think it would be helpful to get answers from
    students with disabilities.

    <jeanne> ... please comment on the document. I'll meet with him
    at 10:00AM.

    [9]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOauw
    9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y

       [9] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOauw9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y

Pete McNally Survey Analysis

    <jeanne>
    [10]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1s__XoEMsuUpsmE48GTE3nUN
    _ERL9UmXfPR_UoCPYxlY/edit?userstoinvite=christopher.loiselle@pe
    rkins.org&ts=59fba970&actionButton=1#heading=h.q6e5fx7mb3iw

      [10] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1s__XoEMsuUpsmE48GTE3nUN_ERL9UmXfPR_UoCPYxlY/edit?userstoinvite=christopher.loiselle@perkins.org&ts=59fba970&actionButton=1#heading=h.q6e5fx7mb3iw

    We need to look at this document, agree on the conclusions and
    then create some slides for TPAC and then once we have agreed
    on everything, we will make this document public

    <jeanne> TPAC slide deck <-
    [11]https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1eqUPEPxIH8AJZ8aVY3-
    vwGMH0sdrXhMG_JCQTp9PSy8/edit#slide=id.g29970d1a13_0_5

      [11] https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1eqUPEPxIH8AJZ8aVY3-vwGMH0sdrXhMG_JCQTp9PSy8/edit#slide=id.g29970d1a13_0_5

    [12]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOau
    w9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y - Tyson
    McMillan research questions

      [12] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kWK-AJ1MTw9jnh8emitgOauw9tfH4EUAzx-rs9rxcxo/edit#heading=h.qv64wjyega4y

    Jeanne: We need feedback on the Pete McNally Report

    [13]https://docs.google.com/document/d/1s__XoEMsuUpsmE48GTE3nUN
    _ERL9UmXfPR_UoCPYxlY/edit?userstoinvite=christopher.loiselle@pe
    rkins.org&ts=59fba970&actionButton=1#heading=h.q6e5fx7mb3iw

      [13] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1s__XoEMsuUpsmE48GTE3nUN_ERL9UmXfPR_UoCPYxlY/edit?userstoinvite=christopher.loiselle@perkins.org&ts=59fba970&actionButton=1#heading=h.q6e5fx7mb3iw

    Jeanne: Under platform focus - Silver has to pursue being
    hardware agnostic - need to look at the wording of this and
    massage it.
    ... look at the comment about some people working in
    environments where accessibility is not valued - do you agree
    or disagree?
    ... look at "what aspects are difficult to apply"

    <jemma> question was " How important is accessibility to your
    company/clients in creating an excellent user/customer
    experience? "

    Ryan: It's important to note in the report that these are the
    opinions of UX professionals surveyed.

    How can the W3C create good standards and work with other
    organizations to create educational resources?

    Jeanne: The W3C should look into how it can be a place that
    points people to the resources they need- if they need an
    example of an accessible carousel, then they could find links
    to some potential resources.
    ... Familiarity and Usefulness section is next
    ... we just have data to share here - not necessarily a
    conclusion

    Jemma: This implies that WCAG has authority, but not
    practicality

    Jeanne: Let's look at aspects that are "difficult to apply"

    Ryan: Mastery is an emotional issue. If people don't feel like
    they can master something, despite their best efforts, they can
    become angry.
    ... The concept of personal mastery is an emotional issue. If
    there is no sense of mastery, then there will be no emotional
    buy-in.

    Jemma: This might be a great topic for our interview research.
    ... We can be successful to certain degree, but if people
    experience barriers to mastery, they may determine
    accessibility cannot be achieved.

    Jeanne: We will not have meetings next week because too many
    people will be at TPAC
    ... Jan and Jeanne will work on this on Sunday to bring it to a
    presentable level
    ... if everyong could please make comments and help us with
    conclusions, then we can polish it off
    ... next meeting is on November 14th

Summary of Action Items

Summary of Resolutions

    [End of minutes]
      __________________________________________________________