Just to clarify my response, I was talking about the final issue disposition, that needs to be copied to the comments list on which the original comment was filed. The preliminary "we're working on it" response does not need to be copied though, that's just admin. Michael On 09/03/2021 1:57 p.m., Michael Cooper wrote: > On 09/03/2021 1:46 p.m., Jeanne Spellman wrote: >> Hi Michael, >> >> I'm working on moving the emails into Github and I have questions. >> >> 1) Should we include the email address of the commenter into GH? At >> first I thought it would be convenient, but then I wondered about >> privacy and how widely we expose email addresses. Thoughts? > There should be a pointer to the comment in the list archives, which > will have the person's email. Therefore, there is no need to copy it > to the github issue, and I recommend against it. >> >> 2) Should my answer be copied to the public AGWG comments list or >> just to the person who made the comments? I didn't want to clutter >> the list archives with a lot of comments, but maybe we need a copy of >> them? > > Definitely copy the list for issues that were filed via the list. We > need a public record of responses traceable from the original message. > > For comments originally filed in GitHub, just the response in the > issue is sufficient, no need to copy comments lists on those as the > list archives wouldn't have context anyways. > > Michael > >> >> >> I've done a few now including one that had to be split up. I think >> that's my questions for now. :) >> >> jeanne >> >>
Received on Wednesday, 10 March 2021 14:36:08 UTC