- From: David Booth <david@dbooth.org>
- Date: Tue, 21 Oct 2014 20:35:29 -0400
- To: w3c semweb HCLS <public-semweb-lifesci@w3.org>
- CC: "Paul A. Knapp" <pknapp@pknapp.com>, Claude Nanjo <cnanjo@cognitivemedicine.com>, Dale Nelson <dale.nelson@squaretrends.com>, Andy Stechishin <andy.stechishin@gmail.com>, michel.dumontier@gmail.com, Josh Mandel <jmandel@gmail.com>, Conor Dowling <conor-dowling@caregraf.com>, Rafael Richards <rmrich5@gmail.com>, Anthony Mallia <amallia@edmondsci.com>, joshua phillips <joshua.phillips@semanticbits.com>, Cecil Lynch <cecil.o.lynch@accenture.com>, Harold R Solbrig <Solbrig.Harold@mayo.edu>, mehmet aydar <mehmetaydar@gmail.com>, Michael.Miller@systemsbiology.org, Marc Twagirumukiza <marc.twagirumukiza@agfa.com>, kashyap.vipul@gmail.com, oya.beyan@deri.org, Tim.Williams@ucb.com, mscottmarshall@gmail.com, jjc@syapse.com, campbell@informatics.com, Peter.Hendler@kp.org, jamie.ferguson@kp.org, kerstin.l.forsberg@gmail.com, haendel@ohsu.edu, Keith W Boone <kwboone@gmail.com>, Alexander Garcia Castro <alexgarciac@gmail.com>, "Jiang, Guoqian, M.D., Ph.D." <Jiang.Guoqian@mayo.edu>, "Sahay, Ratnesh" <ratnesh.sahay@deri.org>, joachim.baran@gmail.com, hanscools@intergga.ch, Sofia Pinto <hsofiapinto@gmail.com>, Grahame Grieve <grahame@healthintersections.com.au>, "Douglas B. Fridsma" <doug.fridsma@hhs.gov>, Charlie Mead <meadch@mail.nih.gov>, charlie.mead@yahoo.com, charles.normanmead@gmail.com, stan.huff@imail.org, eric@w3.org, Marcus Nitzschke <nitzschke@informatik.uni-leipzig.de>, woody@beelers.com
My notes from today's call with the HL7 ITS work group: - We discussed creating a sub-group on "RDF for Semantic Interoperability". There were 13 people on the call. I briefly reviewed the purpose of the activity and the history of this effort to create either an HL7 work group or a subgroup of an existing HL7 work group. I used these slides: http://dbooth.org/2014/hl7/rdf-for-interop.pdf - Everyone seemed in agreement on the idea of starting this work as a sub-group of the HL7 ITS work group, for reasons described in the above slides. - A motion was unanimously passed to create a scope-of-work statement for the sub-group. (This seemed to be the appropriate way to formalize the creation of the sub-group and its purpose.) I (David Booth) took an action to modify the existing draft charter to say "sub-group" instead of "work group" and circulate it (to the ITS group, the W3C HCLS group and anyone else who had specifically indicated an interest). - A doodle poll will be sent out by me (David) to help figure out the best day/time for a weekly sub-group teleconference. The sub-group will also provide updates on the regular weekly ITS call. Poll: http://doodle.com/gpxycd9h2q7t5i4w - I (David) briefly listed a few potential agenda topics for our first sub-group meeting: - We will meet again next week on the regular 2pm (Eastern US) Tuesday ITS teleconference, to agree on the scope-of-work statement and the sub-group teleconference day/time. If anyone has corrections are additions to the above notes, please reply-all. Thanks! David Booth On 10/08/2014 02:00 PM, David Booth wrote: > TELECONFERENCE: > Subject: Initiating HL7 work on "RDF for Semantic Interoperability" > 2:00 PM (US Eastern time) Tuesday 21-Oct-2014 > Phone Number: +1 770-657-9270 > Participant Passcode: 0432811 > Web meeting: https://join.me/paulknapp (click on knock to join) > Duration: 30 minutes > > Slides and charter: http://dbooth.org/2014/hl7/ > > BACKGROUND: > At the invitation of the HL7 ITS work group > http://www.hl7.org/Special/committees/xml/overview.cfm > we have scheduled a teleconference (above) to discuss the start of work > at HL7 on "RDF for Semantic Interoperability". The HL7 AID work group > http://www.hl7.org/Special/committees/java/overview.cfm > is invited to join this call, as are members of the W3C Healthcare and > Life Sciences group and anyone else who is interested in this work. > > When the idea of doing this work at HL7 was first proposed several > months ago by Stan Huff, the thought was to create a new HL7 work group > for it, and a charter was drafted and circulated. However, in > discussions that Claude Nanjo and I had with others at the Chicago HL7 > meetings a couple of weeks ago, there was a suggestion that it may be > more effective to start this work as a sub-group of an existing HL7 work > group -- in particular the ITS work group -- rather than starting a new > work group right away. (Peter Hendler also later suggested that this > work could also fit under the HL7 AID work group.) The motivation for > putting this under an existing HL7 work group is that this would allow > easier assimilation into HL7 processes, facilitate better initial > coordination and networking within HL7, and reduce the risk of this work > being misconstrued as competing with other existing HL7 efforts. Claude > and I both found that reasoning fairly compelling, so we arranged with > HL7 ITS co-chair Paul Knapp to schedule a time during one of the > regularly scheduled ITS calls, for a joint discussion with members of > the AID work group and the W3C community. > > The purpose of this discussion: > > - briefly review the intent of the "RDF for Semantic Interoperability" > work; > > - seek consensus on the forum for starting this work; and > > - set agenda for next teleconference. > > Please join if you can. If anyone is interested in this work, but > cannot join this call, please let me know so that I can still keep you > informed. > > Thanks! > David Booth > > > >
Received on Wednesday, 22 October 2014 00:36:04 UTC