- From: Thomas Hertog <thomas.hertog@gmail.com>
- Date: Fri, 22 Aug 2014 11:56:30 +0200
- To: public-respimg@w3.org
- Message-ID: <CAG8GZ1RHDCd3T3Zy0hYZ3486JM6cbF6my9whMVXsksPcLpevsg@mail.gmail.com>
Dear, first of all, my apologizes if my English isn't well-written. I am not a native speaker but I tried my best. as I was reading about the picture element combined with the srcset attribute, I was excited. Because this time we could have responsive images without the burden of doing all calculations myself. However, the reason I want to use multiple files is performance. I don't want my users to download a 5MB picture when the biggest they can display would contain only 1MB As far as I can understand the specification, this problem is still not solved by using the picture element combined with the srcset and sizes attributes. Because what would happen if a viewport is resized (due to someone simply resizing their browser window, or an orientation change on mobile). Would this mean a new file has to be downloaded for displaying if the new area where the image can be displayed reaches a certain (bigger) threshold? Let me illustrate with an example. A mobile phone with screen size 480x800px navigates to a website. The medium sized image gets downloaded because the phone is held in portrait mode. Once the user rotates his phone and the orientation changes, the browser recalculated and discovered a bigger image could be used. Will this bigger image be downloaded as well? Or will the other image be stretched out? Or even something else I couldn't think of? Regards Thomas
Received on Sunday, 24 August 2014 08:36:58 UTC