Re: against injective annotations - Re: RDF-star "baseline" with IRI opacity

Functional annotations have been dropped already :-)
—e.

> On 14 Jun 2024, at 17:01, Peter F. Patel-Schneider <pfpschneider@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> It has been suggested in the previous version of the "baseline" that annotations should use a predicate that is injective, i.e., each annotation is for a single triple term.  But it is very common to want to provide provenance for not just one triple term but multiple triple terms at once.  Consider John married Suzy in Westminster as evidenced by the New York Times of Tuesday gathered by KRBOT on Wednesday.  Here the annotation is for the entire n-ary relationships John married Suzy in Westminster, not just for John married Suzy and not just for ... in Westminster. As in
>  _:b rdf:isAnnotationOf ( John married Suzy ) .
>  _:b rdf:isAnnotationOf ( ( John married Suzy ) in Westminster ) .
>  _:b :source _:nyt .
>  _:nyt :publication :NYT .
>  _:nyt :date Tuesday .
>  _:b :gathered _:krbot .
>  _:krbot :agent :KRBOT .
>  _:krbot :date Wednesday .
> So requiring annotations to be just for one triple term does not seem desirable.
> 
> peter
> 
> 
>> On 6/14/24 08:20, Franconi Enrico wrote:
>> Hi,
>> after the discussions last week arguing the non-intuitiveness of fully opaque triple terms as literals, and after the comments that opaque tripe terms should have transparent bnodes, I have prepared a new version of the baseline document, where opaque triple terms have opaque IRIs and transparent bnodes:
>> https://github.com/w3c/rdf-star-wg/wiki/RDF-star-"baseline-with-IRI-opacity” <https://github.com/w3c/rdf-star-wg/wiki/RDF-star-"baseline-with-IRI-opacity">
>> Note that annotations are not anymore functional with opaque triple terms anymore, since it would make little sense with transparent bnodes in opaque triple terms. Still, as I already discussed privately with some of you, even without functionality we should still be able to capture the LPG use cases.
>> See you later,
>> —e.
>

Received on Sunday, 16 June 2024 12:23:34 UTC