- From: Roger L. Costello <costello@mitre.org>
- Date: Sun, 21 Mar 2004 07:40:15 -0500
- To: public-qt-comments@w3.org, "Costello,Roger L." <costello@mitre.org>
FUNCTIONALITY REQUESTED The ability to dynamically alter the value of a globally scoped variable. DOMAINS REQUIRING THIS FUNCTIONALITY Multi-agent simulation, parallel processing, complex adaptive systems. REASON FOR REQUIRING THIS FUNCTIONALITY Consider a multi-agent simulation: I would like to have code to express the movement rules for a *single* agent, and then *separately* have code which *applies* the movement rules to each agent (a classic case of separation of concerns, and a classic paradigm of parallel processing). I will show a simple example in pseudocode: Agent Movement Rule Move forward one cell Turn right 90 degrees Move forward 2 cells Agent Processing For each agent do: Apply Agent Movement Rule In this example we see that we have cleanly separated the statement of the how each agent should move (Agent Movement Rule), from the application of the movement rule to each agent (Agent Processing). In order for the Agent Processing code to to apply the Movement Rule code to each agent it will need to modify the value of a global variable. Thus, you now see why I am requesting this functionality. CAN MULTI-AGENT SIMULATION BE DONE WITH EXISTING 2.0 FUNCTIONALITY? Yes. In the above example the Agent Movement Rule could be nested within the Agent Processing code (in fact, I have implemented this). However, it results in (very) brittle, complex code and it does not support separation of concerns (e.g., one person writing the Agent Movement Rule, another person writing the Agent Processing code). NOT TOO LATE, I HOPE! I realize that this request is late in the game. However, I feel that without this functionality the 2.0 version will have a large gaping hole in its capability, and severely cripple multiple communities. Thanks for your time. /Roger
Received on Sunday, 21 March 2004 07:40:20 UTC