W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-pronunciation@w3.org > May 2019

Pronunciation Task Force - A draft of User Scenarios for review

From: Sam Kanta <sam.kanta@thesustainablechange.com>
Date: Wed, 22 May 2019 12:28:02 +0000
To: "public-pronunciation@w3.org" <public-pronunciation@w3.org>
Message-ID: <MWHPR22MB09416844A072A9C867EE0AD187000@MWHPR22MB0941.namprd22.prod.outlook.com>
Introduction

As part of the Accessible Platform Architectures (APA) Working Group, the Pronunciation Task Force (PTF) is a collaboration of subject matter experts working to identify and specify the optimal approach which can deliver reliably accurate pronunciation across browser and operating environments. With the introduction of the Kurzweil reading aid in 1976, to the more sophisticated synthetic speech currently used to assist communication as reading aides for the visually impaired and those with reading disabilities, the technology has multiple applications in education, communication, entertainment, etc. From helping to teach spelling and pronunciation in different languages, Text-to-Speech (TTS) has become a vital technology for providing access to digital content on the web and through mobile devices.

The challenges that TTS introduces is the inability to accommodate regional variations and presentation of every phoneme present throughout the world. A number of markup languages have been established to address these language and pronunciation variations and make the content legible and meaningful. The W3C recommendation, of the Speech Synthesis Markup Language (SSML), provides a promising approach that will be addressed through the Pronunciation Task Force. This document explores requirements based on examples of use cases and scenarios.

User Scenarios

The purpose of developing user scenarios is to facilitate discussion and further requirements definition for pronunciation standards developed within the PTF prior to review of the APA. There are numerous interpretations of what forms user scenario adopts. Within the user experience research (UXR) body of practice, a user scenario is a written narrative related to the use of a service from the perspective of a user or user group. Importantly, the context of use is emphasized as is the desired outcome of use. There are potentially thousands of user scenarios for a technology such as TTS, however, the focus for the PTF is on the core scenarios that relate to the kinds of users who will engage with TTS.

User scenarios, like Personas, represent a composite of real world experiences. In the case of the PTF, the scenarios were derived from interviews of people who were end-consumers of TTS, as well as submitted narratives and industry examples from practitioners. There are several formats of scenarios. Several are general goal or task-oriented scenarios. Others elaborate on richer context, for example, educational assessment.

The following user scenarios are organized on the three perspectives of TTS use derived from analysis of the qualitative data collected from the discovery work:

  *   End-Consumers of TTS Encompasses those with a visual disability or other need to have TTS operational for using assistive technologies (ATs).
  *   Digital Content Managers Addresses activities related to those responsible for producing content that needs to be accessible to ATs and W3C WAI Guidelines.
  *   Software Engineers Includes developers and architects required to put TTS into an application or service.

End-Consumer of TTS

Mary has a visual impairment and uses AT with TTS to help navigate through websites. She needs to travel to Ottawa, Canada and so goes to a travel website to book her flight. Mary already knows the airport code and enters "YOW". The site produces the result in a drop-down list as "Ottawa, CA" but her AT cannot pronounce the text. In frustration, she abandons her search and calls a friend to complete the booking online instead.

As a test taker (tester) with a visual impairment who may use assistive technology to access the test content with speech software, screen reader or refreshable braille device, I want the content to be presented as intended, with accurate pronunciation and articulation, so that my assessment accurately reflects my knowledge of the content.

As a student/learner with auditory and cognitive processing issues, it is difficult to distinguish sounds, inflections, and variations in pronunciation as rendered through synthetic voice, such as text-to-speech or screen readers technologies. Consistent and accurate pronunciation whether human-provided, external, or embedded is needed to support working executive processing, auditory processing and memory that facilitates comprehension in literacy and numeracy for learning and for assessments.

As an English Learner (EL) or a visually impaired early learner using speech synthesis for reading comprehension that includes decoding words from letters as part of the learning construct (intent of measurement), pronunciation accuracy is vital to successful comprehension, as it allows the learner to distinguish sounds at the sentence, word, syllable, and phoneme level.

Cultural Exchange

Contributed by: Paul Grenier on behalf of Pronounce Names<https://nam04.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.pronouncenames.com%2F&data=02%7C01%7Ccloew%40collegeboard.org%7C7ce78410f03c4decff1508d6de21591e%7C7530bdedfd6e4f58b5d2ea681eb07663%7C0%7C0%7C636940632166873932&sdata=pDTePZkb38SC1sPbU%2BGX0tvQTWWMXqu84FEyCDwTiCc%3D&reserved=0>.

Description: A free resource assisting with proper name pronunciation. Currently, users of the site must be familiar with English alphabet pronunciation (romaji when used for Japanese). Linguists providing pronunciation could increase accuracy and expand to languages the English alphabet can not pronounce if it were accessible to users. With Pronunciation standards, users of Pronounce Names could use the browser's Speech Synthesis to speak names using the IPA alphabet.

A person requesting pronunciation for their own name, could use the browser's Speech Synthesis to verify their preferred pronunciation. This could be copied to resumes, social media, vcard, business cards, etc. In the case of "Americanized" names, personal choice is more important than correctness and many alternate pronunciations may exist. For example, the surname "Grenier" has two pronunciations on the site, and my prefered pronunciation is neither of them.

Content Management for TTS

Andrew is a content producer for a global travel e-commerce site where he is responsible for curating text and images for promotional events. His Enterprise is vying to be the preferred vendor for the European Union and in order to do so, they need to be able to provide accessible content for TTS. At present, there is no way he can edit content to pronounce words, other than English, correctly.

Johnny is a translator for indigenous elders in South Australia. His latest assignment requires him to not only translate but to document pronunciation of regional languages within the State on the Project website, given the diversity among tribal groups with pronunciation although having a shared lexicon for common terms for geography, flora, fauna, and climate.

Educational Assessment

In the educational assessment field, providing accurate and concise pronunciation for students with auditory accommodations, such as text-to-speech (TTS) or students with screen readers, is vital for ensuring content validity and alignment with the intended construct, which objectively measures a test takers knowledge and skills.  For test administrators/educator, pronunciations must be consistent across instruction and assessment, in order to avoid test bias or impact effects for students. Some additional requirements for the test administrators, include, but are not limited to, such scenarios:

As a test administrator, I want to ensure that students with the read aloud accommodation who are using assistive technology or speech synthesis as an alternative to a human reader, have the same speech quality (e.g., intonation, expression, pronunciation, and pace, etc.) as spoken language.

As a test administrator, speech accuracy with mathematical expressions, including numbers, fractions, and operations can be difficult to pronounce. Some mathematical expressions required special pronunciations to ensure accurate interpretation while maintaining test validity and construct. Examples include:

  *   Mathematical formulas written in simple text with special formatting, should convey the correct meaning of the expression to identify changes from normal text to super- or to sub-script text.

     *   For example: a3-b3=(a-b)(a2+ab+b2).  Without the proper formatting, this equation may incorrectly render through some technologies and applications as a3-b3=(a-b)(a2+ab+b2).

  *   Distinctions made in writing are often not made explicit in speech; For example, fx may be interpreted as: fx, f(x), fx, F X, F X. The distinction depends on the context; requiring the author to provide consistent an accurate semantic markup.
  *   For math equations with Greek letters, it is important that the speech synthesizer be able to distinguish the phonetic differences between them, whether in the natural language or phonetic equivalents. For example,  (epsilon)  (upsilon)  (phi)  (chi) (xi).



As a test administrator/educator, pronunciations must be consistent across instruction and assessment, in order to avoid test bias and pronunciation effects on performance for students with disabilities (SWD) in comparison to students without disabilities (SWOD). Examples include:

  *   If a test question is measuring rhyming of words or sounds of words, the speech synthesis should not read aloud the words, but rather spell out the words in the answer options
  *   If a test question is measuring spelling and a student needs to consider spelling correctness/incorrectness, the speech synthesis should not read aloud the misspelt words, especially for words, such as:

     *   Heteronyms/homographs: same spelling, different pronunciation, different meanings, such as lead (to go in front of) or lead (a metal); wind (to follow a course that is not straight) or wind (a gust of air); bass (low, deep sound) or bass (a type of fish), etc.
     *   homophone: words that sound alike, such as, to/two/too; there/their/they're; pray/prey; etc.
     *   Homonyms: multiple meaning words, such as, scale (measure) or scale (climb, mount); fair (reasonable) or fair (carnival); suit (outfit) or suit (harmonize); etc.

Education Publishing

As a content developer, I want to create content that can readily be delivered both assistive technology and can convey the correct meaning and ensure that screen readers render the right pronunciation based on the surrounding context.

Academic Research

Contributed by: Paul Grenier on behalf of Lamh<https://nam04.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fxn--lamh-bpa.org%2F&data=02%7C01%7Ccloew%40collegeboard.org%7C7ce78410f03c4decff1508d6de21591e%7C7530bdedfd6e4f58b5d2ea681eb07663%7C0%7C0%7C636940632166903967&sdata=HtlLzo3HlOUkyLjDrEBrJoUalmQgpBkx7Zrzgh%2FrhJ4%3D&reserved=0>.

Description: An academic resource for translation of Irish texts (13th - 18th century) supported by several universities. With pronunciation standards for the web, anthropological linguistics scholars could join the conversation and possibly offer new insights to this academic work. Hearing Early Modern Irish spoken may spark more interest among students to assist with the translations of texts. Many of the studied works were once performed. As linguists map phonemes to synthesized voices, Pronunciation standards can help bring this language "back to life" for historians and Arts programs. Additionally, blind and low vision scholars, unable to read the texts, could assist with additional translations.

Software Application Development

Anna is a developer in a Content Management System (CMS) start-up based in Latvia. The Product Owner is wanting the next release to have the capability of pronouncing speech "just like Alexa can", to demonstrate the start-up's capability in a competitive SaaS space.


________________________________
Sam Kanta, PhD
Principal UX Researcher | W3C Invited Expert
The Sustainable Change LLC

e:  sam.kanta@thesustainablechange.com
p: 208.440.4246


Received on Wednesday, 22 May 2019 12:28:29 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Friday, 17 January 2020 16:49:46 UTC