Re: [pointerevents] Touch-action isn't flexible enough for direction-specific behavior

Oh I forgot you wrote that, sorry!  I think it demonstrates the 
essential point here (a carousel inside something else that scrolls - 
doesn't really matter if that's a pinch viewport or some other 
scroller).  

With `pan-right`/`pan-left` support you can swipe all the way to the 
end of the carousel (49), lift, then drag to scroll the container to 
the right.  Without `pan-right` and `pan-left` I don't think there's 
really any way to make the composition scenario work with pointer 
events.  You have to disallow horizontal panning of the container when
 over the carousel completely.  This means that when pinch-zoomed in 
you may be trapped - unable to pan the viewport without zooming out.

@scottgonzalez I'm curious for your take on this sort of nested 
scrolling scenario.  Seem important to you / jQuery? I know nested 
scrollers are generally an anti-pattern, but they happen all the time 
in pinch-zoom scenarios so can't be ignored completely IMHO.

@NavidZ / @mustaqahmed note that this carousel doesn't appear to work 
correctly in Chrome with pointer event support enabled - want to debug
 to see if it's a known compat issue?

-- 
GitHub Notification of comment by RByers
Please view or discuss this issue at 
https://github.com/w3c/pointerevents/issues/6#issuecomment-221663333 
using your GitHub account

Received on Wednesday, 25 May 2016 18:24:55 UTC