- From: Renato Iannella <ri@semanticidentity.com>
- Date: Fri, 21 Feb 2014 13:58:10 +1000
- To: ODRL Community Group <public-odrl@w3.org>
- Message-Id: <39FCD458-FA32-4FB4-A96F-563A49C1FAFF@semanticidentity.com>
Attached are the notes and actions from the teleconference call to discuss the changes to the common vocabulary (thanks Michael for scribing!) **Please NOTE the Actions *** ODRL Community conf call (by Skype) on 2014-02-19 =========================================== Participants: Renato Iannella /RI, Cindy Lewis /CL, Stuart Myles /SM, Michael Steidl /MS + Victor Rodriguez Doncel /VRD RI: consider to take out these terms - the ONIX terms - Creative Commons - the OMA terms SM: it would be an improvement if we have only clearly defined terms in the vocabulary. CL: who of ONIX was involved? RI: it was Francis Cave UPDATE: Francis has confirmed that ONIX is not using ODRL so there is no impact from removing them RI: CC terms we can move to the ODRL/CC Profile ** Discussions of the definitions proposed by IPTC: RI: they may be too extensive MS: definitions should be as precise as possible - say legal consultants SM: too long definition may be confusing engineers having to implement ODRL MS: pointed out that the definitions also clarify if an action can (only) be used for Perm/Prohib or Duty RI: then we should split up the vocab into a Perm/Prohib Action vocab and a Duty Action vocab - this was agreed by the group RI: asked all on the call for some more comments. The group should come to a conclusion and adopt the proposed changes - after we have taken out the (currently) not required terms. MS: IPTC offers to hand over the action vocabulary to a law firm - for a legal review (and to pay for it). They would return comments and where required alternative wordings. RI: invites MS as representative of IPTC to become the co-editor of the action vocabulary. MS gratefully accepted. RI is working with Roberto García Gonzalez, the creator of a rights expression ontology for this project, on some shared ideas and approaches of mapping ODRL vocab to a broader copyright ontology ****** Next Actions ***** 1 - Remove the terms no longer required (ONIX, OMA, CC) 2 - Update ODRL/CC Profile with terms 3 - Set a due date for final comments on the proposed changes 4 - After the due date: create the final draft Common Vocab document ... 5 - forward this to legal firm for review Cheers... Renato Iannella Semantic Identity http://semanticidentity.com Mobile: +61 4 1313 2206
Received on Friday, 21 February 2014 03:58:44 UTC