Re: Evaluation of ontology reuse choices in real-world scenarios

Hi Ghislain,

I did have the same problem recently. Having as premise reuse of 
ontologies used for modeling my specific domain, I did a empirical 
survey for answering the following questions: Which ontologies are used 
by recent projects and datasets published in my specific domain? I found 
that a few ontologies are continuosly reused by all projects and 
datasets and were the same ontologies used for modeling the dataset in 
my project. What projects and datasets use for doing the survey depend 
of your domain. You can use some tools very interesting available in the 
web, such as [1] and [2]

[1] http://datahub.io/dataset?organization=lodcloud
[2] http://watson.kmi.open.ac.uk/WatsonWUI/index.html

Best regards

Yusniel Hidalgo
El 20/02/2014 15:04, Ghislain Atemezing escribió:
> Hi Bernadette,
> Many thanks for your answer.
>
>> Can you be a bit more specific? Are you looking for evaluation criteria?
> Yes, actually I am looking for evaluation criteria. Let’s say two 
> ontologies X and Y are built for the same domain D, without any 
> Competency Questions (CQ). X and Y reused differently terms from other 
> namespaces. If I was asked to run an experiment with users to evaluate 
> (both qualitative and quantitative) those two ontologies , are they 
> already framework to help me in this task?
>
>>  There is of course basic vocabulary considerations aimed at helping 
>> people review a vocabulary to evaluate its usefulness in the Best 
>> Practices document but presumably you're looking for more or 
>> something different?? [1] 
>
> Thanks again for your advices.
>
> Cheers,
> Ghislain
>
>


________________________________________________________________________________________________
III Escuela Internacional de Invierno en la UCI del 17 al 28 de febrero del 2014. Ver www.uci.cu