- From: Nathan <nathan@webr3.org>
- Date: Wed, 28 Apr 2010 21:47:26 +0100
- To: Mischa Tuffield <mmt04r@ecs.soton.ac.uk>
- CC: Li Ding <dingl@cs.rpi.edu>, Linked Data community <public-lod@w3.org>
Related: http://dev.intellidimension.com/oger/ open graph -> rdf -> sparql and explored via a silverlight front app; worth a look. Best, Nathan Mischa Tuffield wrote: > Hi Li, > > I have just had another look at another user which isn't me (school boy error on my behalf ;) > > http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/borisjohnson > > And I think I found a bug you in your implementation : > > the above rdf document has a dob of which is set to : -1/16/-001 > > Which doesn't seem correct to me, perhaps a bug in your code? > > I looked at boris's public facebook page and, didn't see his dob, > > http://www.facebook.com/borisjohnson#!/borisjohnson?v=info > > but after consulting wikipedia it should be 19th June 1964 > > Anyways, just another pointer. > > Regards, > > Mischa > On 28 Apr 2010, at 21:13, Mischa Tuffield wrote: > >> Hello, >> >> Am cc'ing the foaf-dev mailing (sorry for cross posting)... >> >> I just had a look at your fb graph API -> foaf rdf service[1], firstly cool stuff, but I have a few points I will address below. >> >> I recall Matthew Rowe[2] making a similar service a few years ago which spat out foaf data for a user's fb account, and I recall fb getting annoyed. Am guessing they mentally might have shifted since danbri's good work in getting them involve with SW tech (great work once again by danbri ... *tonnes of applause), I guess we will find out soon ... >> >> My point of reference is my facebook account, and the URI you mint of your service looks like so : >> >> http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat#me >> >> Points: >> >> 1. I would be nice if the person URI you mint, was explicitly a foaf:Person, e.g. : >> >> <http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat#me> a foaf:Person . >> >> 2. The document URI could have a foaf:primaryTopic triple in there such as: >> >> <http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat> foaf:primaryTopic <http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat#me> . >> >> Which in turn identifies which foaf:Person in the RDF document is a "main (wo)man" being defined. This would be useful in the case where the given user's friends are also listed in the document. >> >> 3. Ideally the document URI would be a foaf:PersonalProfileDocument such as : >> >> <http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat> a foaf:PersonalProfileDocument . >> >> 4. Why didn't you make use of foaf:givenname and foaf:familyname which are spec'ed out in the foaf ontology[3], not a biggy but reuse is said to be the right thing™ todo :) >> >> 5. You could add an xsd:dateTime to the dcterms:created triple, as apposed to exposing the data as a plain text literal. >> >> <http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/data/face/resource/mischat> dcterms:created "2010-04-27T12:42:11Z"^^xsd:dateTime . >> >> 6. If i am not mistaken you could also get your hands on my fb avatar URI via the calls you make, that would be nice to see in your rdf. >> >> But yeah, good work :) >> >> >> Mischa *is happy that hardly any of my fb data is accessible via the fb graph API :) >> >> [1] http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/ws/face_lod.html >> [2] <mailto:m.rowe@dcs.shef.ac.uk> >> [3] http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/ >> On 28 Apr 2010, at 15:02, Li Ding wrote: >> >>> I just built a demo that provides dereferenable HTTP URIs (with >>> RDF/XML data) for Facebook data using data retrieved from the recently >>> announced Graph API by Facebook. see >>> http://sam.tw.rpi.edu/ws/face_lod.html >>> >>> In the demo, I observed inconsistent term usage between the Facebook >>> data API (JSON) and open graph protocol vocabulary. There is also >>> some good potential to get the Facebook terms mapped to FOAF and >>> DCterms terms. Please see my blog at >>> http://tw.rpi.edu/weblog/2010/04/28/putting-open-facebook-data-into-linked-data-cloud/ >>> . >>> >>> Comments are welcome. >>> >>> best, >>> >>> -- >>> Li Ding >>> http://www.cs.rpi.edu/~dingl/ >>> > >
Received on Wednesday, 28 April 2010 20:48:08 UTC