Re: Where is the linkage?

Hugh Glaser wrote:
> As some of you have worked out by now, I am getting frustrated trying to
> provide links from my stuff to the other stuff.
> When I do find the links, they may be of dubious quality, but worse still, I
> am having difficulty finding them at all.
> So I started at dbpedia, and followed outgoing arrows.
> Firstly I tried to find some MusicBrainz stuff. No links that I could find
> for the bands and songs I could think of.
> So I saw Gutenburg; excellent, I can't see anything in dbpedia, but finally
> managed to do a SPARQL query on gutenburg (the browsing doesn't seem to
> work), that showed me that gutenburg knows about "Ozma of Oz" and so does
> wikipedia.
> But still no link in dbpedia.
> I am pleased to report that China gets me from dbpedia to the Factbook.
> So I decided to do some looking at links to dbpedia.
> And I found for example that magnatune uses dbpedia country links, which is
> good, but I haven't yet managed to get from Crunchbase to dbpedia for
> something like microsoft.
> So then I look at the (my) RKB cloud, and can report that the links from
> courseware to the outside are all about languages (I think), which would
> disappoint someone coming looking for courses in www.w3.org or dbpedia via
> that route.
>
> Am I doing something wrong here, or is it really the case that our
> much-loved LOD diagrams are misleading, or at best will not give newcomers
> the links they are expecting?
>
> If that is the case, how could we be more clear and helpful?
> And before Michael says it, yes, maybe void is an answer to show people what
> the nature of the links are and where to find them?
>   
Hugh,

We'll something like VoiD is the answer.

The Cloud visual doesn't cut it for figuring out links.

Linking is itself data, and that data is best expressed in a graph, 
hence VoiD.

As for MusicBrainz and DBpedia, that's kinda in flux as the first cut is 
relatively scant, old, and based on Zitgist URIs.  We have a new cut as 
per my mail about MusicBrainz and EC2, and it is based on MusicBrainz 
URIs. We now need to look at how we cleanup DBpedia with this new cut.

Kingsley


> Best
> Hugh.
>
>
> And if I was feeling really frustrated I would remark that more than 10%
> (6/43 or 5/44) of the node links on the famous diagrams are broken. :-)
>
>
>
>   


-- 


Regards,

Kingsley Idehen	      Weblog: http://www.openlinksw.com/blog/~kidehen
President & CEO 
OpenLink Software     Web: http://www.openlinksw.com

Received on Monday, 16 February 2009 00:44:45 UTC