Re: container types

hello,

I agree with Kingsley that <#NetWorth> != <NetWorth>. 

In the spec the networth is never called out as a Concept. It is only ever a Document, e.g. the one at http://example.org/netWorth/nw1/. It isn't the subject of any triple assertions itself. The actual networth is only defined by the individual Assets and Liabilities and by the Individual (linked with netWorthOf). I am not able to refer to JohnZSmiths networth as a concept.

Roger

On 24 Apr 2014, at 21:47, John Arwe wrote:

> > I'm having a little bit of trouble getting your concrete message 
> 
> Roger, let me try this then 
> 
> 1: *If* the example was Gastronomy/likes_food/people, I would agree that (to me) those are "clearly" non-information resources.  Since it's not, limited LDP-practical usefulness. 
> 
> 2: If you're trying to really toe that line in the Primer, you might consider renaming "the bug tracker" example(s) to "the bug Report tracker", independent of anything else. 
> 
> 3: NetWorth, unlike gastronomy, is not "clearly" a non-information resource to me.  I'm not a fanatic about those things typically.  I try to be fanatical about refusing to be fanatical ;-) 
> 
> > I still think that we are doing something 'wrong' in the DC examples
> 
> Suggest a concrete change.  Even if the end result is different or you're not sure yet what end result you do want (you put up a strawman, and the discussion changes your mind and/or others), a strawman often draws out differences that improve mutual understanding.  Think about Sandro's statement last week (I forget the specifics, but it was on paging or patch I think, and it netted out to: it wasn't what I started with, but I'm Very Happy with the conclusion we reached).  That's like The Poster Child for W3C wg process.
> 
> E.g. if you're very very gently suggesting we rename "o:NetWorth" to "o:NetWorthReport" or something like that, "ok" is my reaction.  Since I'm unable to understand clearly what you think we might be doing wrong now, that's my best strawman (and to be clear: I'm not proposing that change myself, even though I would be fine making it ... if it solves your angst, then propose it as a change; if not, find another that would solve your angst).
> 
> 
> That help?
> 
> 
> Best Regards, John
> 
> Voice US 845-435-9470  BluePages 
> Tivoli OSLC Lead - Show me the Scenario 
>