Re: Proposal: normative changes for profiles - 4.5.7 thread

> But, I might restate that as: A vanilla server is just a chocolate 
> server with zero constraints. 

I'm not clear if you are thinking out loud or making a different proposal 
(either is fine).

All I can say is:
- if you are making a concrete proposal, I'd suggest including the new and 
old full text.  People seem to do better with a strawman.
- Assuming that the above corresponds to a proposal to completely replace 
4.5.7, I'd prefer to not entirely lose "make creation easy" thought so I'd 
-0.5 such a proposal.  I am completely open to that becoming a guideline 
as a way to keep it, if that's where WG consensus lands.

Broadly speaking, I agree with the sentiment you expressed, applied to the 
limited context of 4.5.7.  It would need to be re-cast in 2119 language of 
course.

Best Regards, John

Voice US 845-435-9470  BluePages
Tivoli OSLC Lead - Show me the Scenario