Re: [dxwg] Examples in profile guidance

Thanks @agreiner for the comment! And @kcoyle for clarifying. 
Am I right in understanding that this issue is then very close to #366 , as @kcoyle said there that in her mind the 'related work' in section 4 was mostly about giving examples? If yes I'm going to do a cross-reference (and not add a mention of this issue in the doc itself)

Also, in this case I could propose to elaborate on @kcoyle 's suggestion in #366 whereby she suggest to move these 'related work examples' in the introduction. 
I think we won't be able to put a fully fledged description of the examples in the introduction. But what we could do is to have a *brief* description of the 'related work examples' in the intro. We could then compensate for this shortness by coming back to these examples in sections 6 or 7, i.e. as examples of using ProfDesc to create descriptions of profiles and examples of our recommendations being implemented in the wild (even if these implementations are pre-existing to our recommendations, they could still be relevant as examples).

Would this be ok?

GitHub Notification of comment by aisaac
Please view or discuss this issue at using your GitHub account

Received on Tuesday, 2 October 2018 20:50:50 UTC