[dxwg] Jaroslav's profiles ont doc edits

nicholascar has just created a new issue for https://github.com/w3c/dxwg:

== Jaroslav's profiles ont doc edits ==
>From https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-dxwg-wg/2018Nov/0402.html:

- the introductory sentence is opaque, abstract and provides no clues about the purpose/use of the document,
  replace by a more "introductory" section.

 "An ontology for listing the set of resources required for a standard or a profile of one or more standards,
 such as schemas, ontologies, and rules, and for specifying the relationships between them and supporting artefacts,
 such as controlled vocabularies, validation tools, and guidelines."

- section 1. Introduction
    "The profiles ontology provides a structure to describe profiles of information standards."
    - is the target of profiles really "information standards" or something like "digital contents"?
    
    - introduce the verb "profile" in a technical sense, i.e. as adding constraints resolved according to
      inheritance rules defined at X. Otherwise sentences like "Standards which do profile others" are hard to
      interpret

- section 5. Conceptual model
    - the "profile of" relation between base and specialized specifications (profiles) does not match my naive intuition,
      a profile would -extend-> a base profile, while it is -profile of-> digital content that adheres to it?

- section 6.5. Class: ResourceDescriptor
    - could not the dcat:Resource / Distribution content model be reused here to capture the implementation of the profile (part)
      (which does not match the "alignment PROF classes with DCAT 1.1")

- section 6.5.4 hasRole
    - is there a (preliminary) vocabulary of roles (e.g. as given in examples) defined?


Please view or discuss this issue at https://github.com/w3c/dxwg/issues/570 using your GitHub account

Received on Tuesday, 13 November 2018 21:19:20 UTC