DUV minor errors and thougths

Hi,

Some minor errors I found in DUV doc:

1. diagram namespaces of app:Application and app:developedBy:
duv:Application
duv:developedBy

2. Property retains:
both the Definition and the rdfs:subPropertyOf seem to be copied from
hasCitingEntity

3. Example 3 - oa:hsBody:
oa:hasBody

Some thoughts:
I hope my confusing could contribute to clarify some terms of DUV.

I am wondering if the the term "usage" is being used with two different
meanings, before and after using a Dataset.

-- Audience description -- "The DUV is intended for data producers and
publishers interested in tracking, sharing, and persisting consumer dataset
usage. It is also intended for collaborators who require an exchange medium
to advertise and interactively convey dataset usage."

-- duv:Experience definition -- "Information or instructions related to the
usage of the dataset.". (A future use)

In this sense, Experience is info "before using a dataset" and Feedback is
info "after using a Dataset". Both are related to "usage" but in different
perspectives of time.

The property "duv:consumes" from a "duv:Experience", although it resembles
the word "consumer", is related to Application and to WebThing, but it is
not related to a consumer that, for example, download a Dataset or browse
it using CKAN or Socrata, and from that usage, provides a Feedback. I
understand that the word Experience is used in the diagram as a kind of
"instructions and help", and, in this sense, it is not that kind of
Experience of the user when using the Dataset. But the word Experience
together with consumes brought that thoughts to me when I first saw the
diagram.

As I try to explain in the meeting, Experience seems to me a thing that
someone has when it is using a Dataset and from that Experience she could
provide a Feedback. (This is the meaning of the word "Experiência" in
Portuguese. Maybe I am misunderstanding the meaning in English. Another
word is "Experimento", in english "Experiment").

Well, only thinking. As we saw in BP doc (glossary), the meaning of a term
is always a hard thing to convey.

Cheers,
Laufer

-- 
.  .  .  .. .  .
.        .   . ..
.     ..       .

Received on Friday, 29 May 2015 15:46:54 UTC