Re: shapes-ISSUE-187 (severity and message): sh:severity and sh:message are not defined as shapes graph properties

On the use of sh:message, I had raised ISSUE-178. In addition to this, 
sh:message can be used in constraint components and sh:sparql 
constraints (SHACL Full), both in the shapes graph. Section 3.4 also 
explicitly states

"The values of|sh:message|are not mandated by SHACL and are considered 
implementation-specific."

What additional aspects of sh:message are you referring to here?

On sh:severity, section 3.4.9 explains how it is used in shapes graphs.

"Constraints may specify their severity level in theshapes graph 
<#dfn-shapes-graph>using the property|sh:severity|,..."

I do not understand what you think is missing.

Holger


On 9/10/2016 12:46, RDF Data Shapes Working Group Issue Tracker wrote:
> shapes-ISSUE-187 (severity and message): sh:severity and sh:message are not defined as shapes graph properties
>
> http://www.w3.org/2014/data-shapes/track/issues/187
>
> Raised by: Karen Coyle
> On product:
>
> sh:severity and sh:message are described in the validation report, but are not included as properties in the shapes graph even though they are intended to be controlled by the shapes graph. It seems that they would be coded with the specific constraints to which they apply.
>
> There is a default for sh:severity, but the validation report section (3.) does not give any information about the source of the sh:message information. Presumably the only source of messages is the constraints graph. If there is any other source of messages, it is not stated here.
>
>
>