Re: Comments on mobileOK Basic 20070928 draft ( LC-1896 LC-1897 LC-1898 LC-1899 LC-1900 LC-1901 LC-1902 LC-1903 LC-1904 LC-1905 LC-1906 LC-1907 LC-1908 LC-1909)

On 10/26/07, Johannes Koch <johannes.koch@fit.fraunhofer.de> wrote:
> Hmm, no, it's not clear. That means you have to update totals only for
> main ("under test") or included resources with status code 3xx, 401 and
> 407? Not even for 200? Sounds strange to me.

On a success code like 200, you would proceed with tests like
PAGE_SIZE_LIMIT, which ask you to count the size of the body and so
on. This test condition asks you to add to that count the size of
previous responses in the conversation that occurred before that 200,
like a 302 or a 401.

On an error, you would simply stop before running tests so it is not important.

> Additionally, 2.4.3 mentions the "resource under test" and "included
> resources", whereas 3.6 says you have to count "included resources". So
> the "resource under test" does not contribute to the "count total"?

I think the wording isn't quite clear here -- yes the idea is to
include the markup, the "resource under test", in the total, but
reading it again that is not made clear. Jo I am going to slip in a
final editorial change on this too as part of our wrap-up to last call
comments and transition to CR.

Received on Friday, 26 October 2007 21:34:32 UTC