Re: [Bug 21550] New: PannerNode - include informative note on HRTF, point to reference/open examples

On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 10:22 PM, Chris Lowis <chris.lowis@bbc.co.uk> wrote:

> My thinking here was that there's a couple of nodes in the spec that are
> perhaps hard to specify mathematically (the compressor node, for
> example) and that even if we could, my preference leans towards
> attempting to specify the intended effect while leaving implementations
> to compete in terms of performance or sound quality. Is that even a
> desirable goal?
>

I think allowing browsers to compete on quality is fine if authors always
agree on which outputs are higher quality, i.e. that for given outputs A
and B either everyone agrees that A is at least as good as B, or everyone
agrees that B is at least as good as A, and everyone understands that both
A and B are acceptable outputs according to the spec, and the difference in
output is not so large that authors don't trust it.

I worry that this won't be the case for competing HRTF models. I don't know
enough about HRTF but isn't it the case that different developers favour
different models?

In the case of the HRTF setting for the Panner node my preference would
> be:
>
> - allow developers to load their own HRTF into the Node[1]
> - word the spec such that an implementation MAY provide a default HRTF
>   set, and if they do,
> - it SHOULD be derived from the IRCAM set that Webkit have used up to
>   this point.
>

I don't think we should allow implementations to vary based on whether an
HRTF set is provided. Either all should or none should, and since Webkit
does, that means all should.

Letting authors supply their own HRTF sounds great but it could wait for a
later iteration of the spec I think.

Rob
-- 
q“qIqfq qyqoquq qlqoqvqeq qtqhqoqsqeq qwqhqoq qlqoqvqeq qyqoquq,q qwqhqaqtq
qcqrqeqdqiqtq qiqsq qtqhqaqtq qtqoq qyqoquq?q qEqvqeqnq qsqiqnqnqeqrqsq
qlqoqvqeq qtqhqoqsqeq qwqhqoq qlqoqvqeq qtqhqeqmq.q qAqnqdq qiqfq qyqoquq
qdqoq qgqoqoqdq qtqoq qtqhqoqsqeq qwqhqoq qaqrqeq qgqoqoqdq qtqoq qyqoquq,q
qwqhqaqtq qcqrqeqdqiqtq qiqsq qtqhqaqtq qtqoq qyqoquq?q qEqvqeqnq
qsqiqnqnqeqrqsq qdqoq qtqhqaqtq.q"