Re: [web-annotation] Selector Fragment URI Usage in HTML Serialization Note

I didn't see the ipr check issue initially, so I guess merging should 
wait for Ivan since I don't know what he does to fix that?

As for the substance of the examples, interesting but now that I look 
more closely, are we stretching the scope of the Note a little too 
far? As it stands are these annotations or just uses of selectors to 
identify the sources of quotes - i.e., just instances of the 
ResourceSelection class as described in the Selector Note? If so, and 
given that the other examples are annotations, probably should be more
 explicit about this distinction in introducing these examples. But if
 others are also, I'm okay if we want to include examples of 
ResourceSelection class. 

It took me a bit to imagine what the json-ld for these examples would 
look like. Could we provide json-ld equivalents? Ivan's converter tool
 does a nice job with these, I think.

And lastly, these are using Text Position Selector without State 
(which is recommended). Okay, but perhaps we should mention somewhere 
that a refinedBy could be added to align with the recommendation in 
the data model - albeit making everything more complicated (so let's 
not show).  Presumably the document targeted is relatively static with
 no real dynamic content. Might need to say this too.  

GitHub Notification of comment by tcole3
Please view or discuss this issue at 
using your GitHub account

Received on Friday, 27 January 2017 23:17:06 UTC