AW: Call for Consensus: publish FPWD of Web Annotation Model with short name annotation-model; respond by 2 December 2014.

Dear chairs,

thanks for your work on the draft, +1 for publication.

Here are two points I found when reviewing the document (to be addressed after FPWD):

3.2.2 Vocabulary for body and target classes: dctypes:Images is defines as broader than dctypes:StillImage and dctypes:MovingImage, shouldn't we thus use dctypes:StillImage in this list instead of/in addition to dctypes:Image ?

3.2.5 Tags: The fact that tags need to be both of type oa:Tag and oa:EmbeddedContent is not elegant and may be a source of errors. As SemanticTag is a specialisation of Tag, I understand that Tag cannot be defined to imply EmbeddedContent. A solution could be to have Tag as an abstract class, and define another specialisation (e.g., TextTag, TTag, ...) defined as being a specialisation of oa:Tag and oa:EmbeddedContent and used for tags with literal text.

Best regards,
Werner

-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: Frederick Hirsch [mailto:w3c@fjhirsch.com] 
Gesendet: Montag, 17. November 2014 15:35
An: W3C Public Annotation List
Cc: Frederick Hirsch
Betreff: Call for Consensus: publish FPWD of Web Annotation Model with short name annotation-model; respond by 2 December 2014.

This is a Call for Consensus (CfC)  to publish a First Public Working Draft (FPWD) of the 'Web Annotation Data Model' produced by the Annotation Working Group, and adopting the short name of "annotation-model" for this specification [1]

The publication draft is here: http://w3c.github.io/web-annotation/model_fpwd/static.html

Please review and note any concerns on the public list ( public-annotation @ w3.org ). This CfC ends in two weeks, Tuesday  2 December 2014. 

Please note that a FPWD is just that, a first public draft, so it need not be perfect and subsequent change is possible; publishing this draft should give it further review and attention. 

Please respond to this CfC (even a +1 is useful). Silence will be considered agreement. The anticipated publication date is 14 December.

Thanks

regards, Frederick and Rob

Frederick Hirsch, Nokia
Rob Sanderson, Stanford
Co-Chairs W3C Web Annotation WG

[1] please note those on the teleconference 12 November agreed to this short name: http://www.w3.org/2014/11/12-annotation-minutes.html#item04

Received on Friday, 28 November 2014 16:54:11 UTC