- From: Daniel Campos Ramos <danielcamposramos.68@gmail.com>
- Date: Thu, 4 Dec 2025 06:34:23 -0300
- To: public-aikr@w3.org
- Message-ID: <0752b398-1955-4458-b541-3ab2092164b4@gmail.com>
Hi Paola, Thanks for the follow-up. I want to address each point clearly: 1. MVCIC demo was shared, and you cut it short. During the TPAC breakout session (Oct 2025), I began walking through the API-less orchestration demo. The recording shows you stopping it due to the five-minute slot: “OK, about time to stop. We now reached our third five-minute slot for recording.” That’s why you didn’t see the full run—there wasn’t enough time/interest allocated and you cut me out starting my explanation (to present nothing). You even acknowledge it here: "Inspired by Daniel's fast outputting AI powered machine, although still needing much refinement, jotted down some thoughts towards the possiblity of AI powered web standards generator *possibly still science fiction, but since reality is moving so fast." https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-aikr/2025Nov/0006.html But then you never properly attributed my work - Please, be honest, do not steal peoples work this way, stop being dissimulated, please. 2. The notebook has been open and duly credited since day one. As stated earlier, the NotebookLM is just a personal study aid with links to all original docs. You’ve had edit rights since it was created, and every entry cites the original source. I’ve now added a prominent disclaimer reminding readers that official contributions must go through the CG tools. Here's a print screen, since you do not have time to click a link and read a phrase someone shares. 3. Attribution timeline matters. MVCIC (docs/multi_vibe_orchestration in the K3D repo) was first shared on Oct 9 (AIKR list) and Oct 30 (internal list). Your Human Process of Web Standards Generation doc is stamped Created Nov 10, 2025. The new “AI-Driven Web Standards Specification” CG was proposed Nov 17 and launched Nov 28 (see https://www.w3.org/community/blog/2025/11/17/proposed-group-ai-driven-web-standards-specification-community-group/ and https://www.w3.org/community/aiwss/). Given that sequence, it’s hard to treat the AI-driven standards initiative as unrelated to work already discussed in AIKR. 4. MVCIC isn’t “outside scope.” MVCIC is documented with explicit KR vocabularies, reproducible workflows, and KR alignment notes already in the AIKR mailing list and wiki. If there are specific labels or formats you’d like, point me to them—I’ll adapt accordingly. The code itself lives in https://github.com/danielcamposramos/Knowledge3D/ under docs/multi_vibe_orchestration. It’s been public since October. 5. The LLM Council repo is newer. Karpathy’s repo (https://github.com/karpathy/llm-council) was published in late November, so it couldn’t have been the basis for your Nov 10 technical note. That further supports the need for proper attribution of earlier work already in this CG. I hope that clarifies the timeline. I’ll be happy to repost the MVCIC demo links (or run them live) if needed—just let me know if this time you’re available. Best, Daniel
Received on Thursday, 4 December 2025 09:34:39 UTC