- From: Kevin B. McCarty <kmccarty@Princeton.EDU>
- Date: Sun, 30 Sep 2001 16:20:39 -0400 (EDT)
- To: <www-patentpolicy-comment@w3.org>
Dear W3C: I would like to thank you for your role in the standardization and growth of the open WWW thus far. Please be aware that my vehemence is directed solely at this recently proposed Patent Policy. It should be clear from the mailing list archives that the vast majority of people responding are against it. Why? Your definition of a Reasonable And Non-Discriminatory license says that it "may be conditioned on payment of reasonable, non-discriminatory royalties or fees." This is meaningless and tautological without a better specification of "reasonable" and "non-discriminatory." Many (I would guess most) of the individuals who publish on the WWW do so for their own satisfaction (personal web pages), for sharing their work with others (e.g. authors of Free Software), for allowing the distribution of information (universities), or for charitable reasons (e.g. the Red Cross). These individuals cannot afford any licensing scheme which would be easily within the reach of the corporations who appear to have bought themselves seats on the Patent Policy Working Group. (Where are the representatives from the Internet community on this working group?? The FAQ gave only a list of corporations.) As at least one other person has pointed out, the only licensing policies which would be non-discriminatory to these members of the community are 1) royalty-free, or 2) fee is a fixed percentage of the profits. I urge you to revoke this proposed patent policy. The only truly open standards are free ones (in both senses of the word "free") which should be driven by the desires of everyone using the WWW, not just a few large companies hoping to make more money. The WWW has developed so much with the previous royalty-free standard that changing it now would be an act of sheer idiocy. Sincerely, Kevin McCarty (writing for myself, not for my institution)
Received on Sunday, 30 September 2001 16:20:41 UTC