Re: Plenary agenda June 5

some examples:

  * Requirement: Profiles may provide rules on cardinality of terms
    (including “recommended”) [ID41] (5.41) [profile]
  * Requirement: Profiles may provide rules governing value validity
    [ID41] (5.41) [profile]
  * Requirement: Profiles may express dependencies between elements of
    the vocabulary (if A then not B, etc.) [ID41] (5.41) [profile]
  * Requirement: Profiles can have rules for data value validation,
    including pick lists [ID46] (5.46) [profile]


On 6/2/18 12:17 AM, Karen Coyle wrote:
> I'm not sure which ones you see as requirements for a spec. Can you give
> a couple of examples?
>
> My take is that as we were developing the use cases most of them were
> about requirements for profiles, not requirements for a profile guidance
> document. And we would take those requirements for profiles and turn
> them into a guidance document.
>
> kc
>
> On 6/1/18 9:06 PM, Annette Greiner wrote:
>> Are these supposed to be requirements as in
>>
>>    "these are the things the spec we are writing needs to accomplish"
>>
>> or requirements as in
>>
>>    "these are the things a profile needs to have to be a profile"?
>>
>> To me, the requirements listed on the agenda read as the latter, which
>> are the contents of a spec (e.g., they use terms like "can" and "may"),
>> but other requirements in the GDoc read as the former, which are
>> requirements for a spec.
>>
>> -Annette
>>
>>
>> On 6/1/18 6:54 AM, Karen Coyle wrote:
>>> https://www.w3.org/2017/dxwg/wiki/Meetings:Telecon2018.06.05
>>>
>>> Jaroslav organized the requirements into categories, and the first few
>>> categories are in the agenda for our discussion. PLEASE take a look at
>>> them and be ready to vote. We will try to vote on entire categories
>>> unless there are objections to specific requirements. If you will not be
>>> at the meeting but wish to comment or vote, you may do so in email and
>>> we will do our best to include your views.

-- 
Annette Greiner
NERSC Data and Analytics Services
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory