- From: Henrik Frystyk Nielsen <henrikn@microsoft.com>
- Date: Wed, 5 Jun 2002 11:58:00 -0700
- To: "Anish Karmarkar" <Anish.Karmarkar@oracle.com>, <w3c-xml-protocol-wg@w3.org>
- Cc: <xmlp-comments@w3.org>, "Ramesh Seshadri" <ramesesh@microsoft.com>, "Paul Cotton" <pcotton@microsoft.com>, "Alex DeJarnatt" <alexdej@microsoft.com>, "Kirill Gavrylyuk" <kirillg@microsoft.com>
Thanks for the review, >> * Test:T1.4.2 >> >> Is the assertion in the description correct ? >> > >Hmm. This test got added as a result of resolution of issue 194, which >says that: >"The encoding style attribute MUST NOT appear in ANY element defined in >the envelope namespace" I think it has been changed to where it MAY appear rather than where it MUST NOT appear. It might have been clearer by saying where it MUST NOT appear but I can go either way. >> * Test:Mark142 >> >> This test shows the generation of a rpc:ProcedureNotPresent fault >> subcode but this is not required anymore (it is a MAY). Hence this >> response is not guaranteed. An equally valid response would not have >> this subcode. >> > >That is quite true. The test collection does a lot of things that are >not required (RPC, soap encoding are optional), but aid interop >implementations. It seems to me that this test would aid interop >implementations. This IMO this should be clearly marked and alternatives at least called out. >> * Test:standalone-test >> >> The request message has standalone='yes', this corresponds to XML 1.0 >> [2], but SOAP 1.2 specifies "true" [3]. This has been reported to the >> SOAP 1.2 spec editors as a bug. >> > >'yes' will be changed to 'true'. No, 'yes' was correct, it was a spec bug (which has been fixed). >> * Test:encodingStyle-on-env-test >> >> It is not clear what assertion is being tested by this test. > >This test got added as a result of resolution of issue 194, which says >that: >"The encoding style attribute MUST NOT appear in ANY element defined in >the envelope namespace" > >But I do not see this text in the latest spec. >Is this an issue against the spec? Same as comment above - encodingStyle can not appear on elements directly defined by envelope schema. >> Proposal for some additions to the test suite >> --------------------------------------------- >> >> * May want to add a test for Nested Structs. >> > >I think that this is a good idea. I believe SOAP builders >round 2 (base) >has a echoStruct test. This can be ported to SOAP 1.2 > >> * When unsupported Content-Type is sent, the response should >be that of >> Http Error 415. > >Good idea. Will be added. > >> >> * When the request for an array doesn't explicitly mention >an ItemType >> attribute in it, the server should be able to handle the response. >> > >A test for this scenario will be added. Great - thanks! Henrik
Received on Wednesday, 5 June 2002 14:58:33 UTC