- From: Stevens, Pat <stevens@oclc.org>
- Date: Fri, 28 Sep 2001 22:50:55 -0400
- To: www-zig@w3.org
Unfortunately, I can't attend the ZIG next week. So, I wanted to share my views on the need for ZNG or something like it. In my job at OCLC, I have spent a good deal of time the last two years talking with librarians about their needs in today's fast-moving climate. I have identified three areas that standards like Z39.50 can be helpful. 1) As Sebastian has stated quite clearly, libraries need Z39.50 to support cooperation and resource sharing among themselves. National and regional governments are interested in facilitating resource sharing because it enables them to maximize the dollars they spend on libraries, a core cultural asset. This is a business-to-business relationship solely among libraries. 2) As Thomas Place of Tilburg commented, libraries also want 'to give integrated access to scientific information sources' and other network resources not under their direct control. An increasing amount of library budgets are being spent on licensing electronic resources which reside somewhere else on the network. This is BtoB with the library as the service manager, and Information Provider as supplier. The providers do not have the same interests as librarians and they don't have government funding as an inducement. It would seem that since libraries are the buyers in this relationship that they would be able to set the standards for access. For complex reasons, that doesn't seen likely to happen. Integration approaches that are easier to implement could help make this integration possible. 3) Libraries would like to help users seeking information elsewhere on the Web aware of the print and electronic resources available through the library. They would like to help users accessing search engines and other online resources like encyclopedias to find related information that their library can provide. In a similar fashion, university libraries want to integrate library resources into online curriculum management. This is the reverse of case 2 as the library is the provider and the other party is managing the service. Libraries must offer access methods that allow service providers to use familiar tools and technology if they are going to be successful in integrating library information into other portals. I believe that ZNG or something like it can help with all three cases, but it seems necessary to achieve what libraries need in case 2 and case 3. I believe that there are other communities besides libraries with related needs that a ZNG-like protocol could help, but I can only speak specifically about libraries. I wish you all a fruitful and productive discussion -- wish I could be there! Pat Pat Stevens Director, Product Planning and Strategy OCLC email: pat_stevens@oclc.org phone: 614-764-6406
Received on Friday, 28 September 2001 22:50:58 UTC