Minutes, 20-21 July 2005 WS Description FTF

Encl.  [Please verify attendance list!]  Summary follows:

Wed 20 July
 Future FTFs:
  Sept 29-30 Bay Area(host TBD)
  Nov 9-11 Tokyo (Hitachi)

 LC75f: 
  ACTION: Editors to incorporate amended proposal from Jonathan as
          regards LC75f resolution (attributes for RPC).
  ACTION: Marsh to respond to all comments.

 LC76c:
  ACTION: Part two editors to incorporate text for section on security 
          considerations, as approved

 LC91:
  ACTION: Arthur to investigate LC91/96 and Noah's proposed rewording

 LC84b:
  RESOLUTION: No action

 Hugo notes a bug re: soapAction
  ACTION: editors to clarify that setting wsoap:action sets the soap 
          action property on all messages in operation.

 LC72:
  RESOLUTION: LC72 to be returned to objector with the summary agreed;
              if faults aren't characterized, then we can't usefully 
              offer further guidance in the specification

 LC91:
  ACTION: editors to incorporate the proposed text from Noah for LC96
          into section 4.2 of part one.

 LC96:
  ACTION: editors to replace "with some additional restrictions" in
          section 3.1.1 by "with the differences defined in this and 
          the following section."
  ACTION: Marsh to reply to Noah about LC91(?) saying that our spec 
          already covers his concern

 LC76d:
  ACTION: dorchard to respond to commenter on keeping mustUnderstand



Thur 21 July
 LC124:
  RESOLUTION: Close with no action; there may be formal objections; the
              WG may pursue this topic within the context of a separate
              deliverable.
  ACTION: pauld to write a proposal for a working group report for
          requirements for schema evolution following closure of LC124

 LC76d:
  ACTION: Editors of Part 2 to implement 1a (error if mustUnderstand 
          conflicts with schema def)
  RESOLUTION: Proposal accepted: "{mustUnderstand} REQUIRED. A 
              xs:boolean. When its value is "true", the SOAP header 
              block MUST be decorated with a SOAP mustUnderstand 
              attribute information item with a value of "true". 
              Otherwise, no additional constraint is placed on the 
              presence and value of a SOAP mustUnderstand attribute 
              information item.

 Last Call:
  RESOLUTION: Publish core, adjuncts, primer, soap 1.1 binding as LC
  	        (ending 19 Sept.)

 Alternative Schema Languages note:
  ACTION: amy to write abstract for alt schema languages and to do some
          cleanup under jonathan's direction
  ACTION: editors of note to add references to wsdl documents (RNG,
          etc.)
  RESOLUTION: publish document as a wg note after some editorial work

 Common Schema Structures:
  Tabled until Sept. FTF.

 Formal Objections:
  ACTION: amy to withdraw Tibco's participation from the formal 
          objection on the ONR
  ACTION: arthur to review the status of IBM's formal objection to 
          the ONR
  ACTION: jonathan to review the status of Microsoft's formal 
          objection to the ONR

 Test Assertions:
  RESOLUTION: Each assertion will be marked up in the spec with a stable
              Identifier.
  [ACTION: Arthur to add stable identifiers for each assertion.]