www-webont-wg@w3.org from December 2002 by date

Wednesday, 1 January 2003

outstanding action items done Deborah McGuinness
Re: Feature Synopsis Review Deborah McGuinness

Tuesday, 31 December 2002

Re: review of Reference, Guide, and Features Jeff Heflin
Re: Semantic Review Jeremy Carroll
Re: Semantic Review Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Semantic Review Jeremy Carroll
Re: doing unnecessary work to keep Jeremy happy Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: doing unnecessary work to keep Jeremy happy Jeremy Carroll
rdfs:Datatype vs owl:Datatype Peter F. Patel-Schneider
doing unnecessary work to keep Jeremy happy Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Overall review Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Semantic Review Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Proposal to reopen issue 5.3 semantic layering Jeremy Carroll
Re: Feature Synopsis Review Jim Hendler
RE: Suntax comments on the Guide document Smith, Michael K
Overall review Jeremy Carroll
Semantic Review Jeremy Carroll
Reference Review Jeremy Carroll
Guide review Jeremy Carroll
Feature Synopsis Review Jeremy Carroll
Re: Suntax comments on the Guide document Jeremy Carroll
Background for reviews Jeremy Carroll
information description of OWL/DL graphs Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Suntax comments on the Guide document Jerome Euzenat
Re: LANG: Defn of DL in Mappings Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: keeping Jeremy happy Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Jim Hendler
Re: LANG: Defn of DL in Mappings Jim Hendler
Re: review of Guide Jim Hendler
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: LANG: Defn of DL in Mappings Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: review of Guide Peter F. Patel-Schneider
RE: keeping Jeremy happy Jeremy Carroll
RE: review of Reference, Guide, and Features Jeremy Carroll
Reviews of OWL documents Ian Horrocks
Review of Web Ontology Language (OWL) Test Cases shimizu
RE: review of Reference, Guide, and Features Smith, Michael K
RE: review of Reference, Guide, and Features Smith, Michael K
keeping Jeremy happy Peter F. Patel-Schneider

Monday, 30 December 2002

Action: Review of satisfaction of requirements Jeff Heflin
Re: review of Reference, Guide, and Features Jeremy Carroll
Re: OWL/DL in RDF graphs Jeremy Carroll
Re: Requirements Document - Latest Version Jeff Heflin
review of Reference, Guide, and Features Peter F. Patel-Schneider
XML presentation syntax Schemas for OWL Lite/DL/Full Masahiro Hori
OWL/DL in RDF graphs Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: SEM: Layering bug Jeremy Carroll
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Jim Hendler
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Mike Dean
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Jeremy Carroll

Friday, 27 December 2002

review of RDF LCC documents Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Dlmcg1@aol.com

Thursday, 26 December 2002

Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Leo Obrst
Re: Abstract Syntax and Semantics: review comments Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Dlmcg1@aol.com
WOWG: Preliminary Face to Face Agenda Jim Hendler

Wednesday, 25 December 2002

Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Leo Obrst

Tuesday, 24 December 2002

Re: WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Jos De_Roo
WOWG: Documents to review (all members - deadlines included) Jim Hendler
Re: Abstract Syntax and Semantics: review comments herman.ter.horst@philips.com

Monday, 23 December 2002

RE: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Peter Crowther
RE: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Peter Crowther
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Jonathan Borden

Sunday, 22 December 2002

Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Ian Horrocks
RE: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Ian Horrocks

Saturday, 21 December 2002

Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Jos De_Roo
ADMIN: minutes of Dec 19th telecon (amended) Ian Horrocks

Friday, 20 December 2002

RE: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Smith, Michael K
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Frank van Harmelen
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Jim Hendler
Re: ADMIN: minutes of Dec 19th telecon Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: SEM: Layering bug Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Abstract Syntax and Semantics: review comments Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Abstract Syntax and Semantics: review comments herman.ter.horst@philips.com
RE: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Peter Crowther
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Dan Connolly
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: ADMIN: minutes of Dec 19th telecon Dan Connolly
Re: SEM: Layering bug Dan Connolly
RE: LANG: Defn of DL in Mappings Jeremy Carroll
SEM: Layering bug Jeremy Carroll
ADMIN: minutes of Dec 19th telecon Ian Horrocks
Reference document: a review herman.ter.horst@philips.com
LANG: Defn of DL in Mappings Jeremy Carroll
TEST,GUIDE,LANG: cardinality and DTDs Jeremy Carroll
WOWG: Congrats to All Jim Hendler

Thursday, 19 December 2002

RE: Complexity and implementability of OWL languages Ian Horrocks
Events at OMG related to using UML as an OWL presentation syntax Evan Wallace
Re: How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Evan Wallace
new XML presentation syntax Schema Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Requirements Document - Latest Version Deborah McGuinness
owl:versionInfo (was Re: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12) Mike Dean
Re: Requirements Document - Latest Version Jim Hendler
Re: Requirements Document - Latest Version Dan Connolly
URIs for user-defined datatypes for use in OWL Dan Connolly
RE: Complexity and implementability of OWL languages Jeremy Carroll
Re: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12 Jeff Heflin
Re: How to close issue 5.8 datatypes Dan Connolly
Re: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12 Leo Obrst
Complexity and implementability of OWL languages Ian Horrocks
WOWG: Working Group has been extended Jim Hendler
RE: ADMIN: Agenda/Logistics for Dec 19 telecon-dialing in at 12:40 - Marwan Marwan Sabbouh
Re: Issue 5.17 XML presentation syntax for OWL Peter F. Patel-Schneider
TEST: xml entitites in test cases? Jeremy Carroll
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Jeremy Carroll
OWL Reference: Latest version Mike Dean
Re: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12 Mike Dean
Re: How to close issue 5.8 datatypes Mike Dean
ADMIN: Agenda/Logistics for Dec 19 telecon Jim Hendler
Re: How to close issue 5.18 - unique names (was RE: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12) Jos De_Roo

Wednesday, 18 December 2002

Requirements Document - Latest Version Jeff Heflin
Guide: Latest version Smith, Michael K
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Dan Connolly
How to close issue 5.18 - unique names (was RE: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12) Jim Hendler
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Mike Dean
Admin: regrets Dec 19 Smith, Michael K
RE: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12 Smith, Michael K
Re: LANG: owl:Thing subClassOf owl:Thing Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: oneOf explicit dt values Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Jeremy Carroll
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Jeremy Carroll
LANG: owl:Thing subClassOf owl:Thing Jeremy Carroll
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Regrets for f2f and 2002-12-19 and 2003-01-02 telecons Nick Gibbins
TEST: latest draft - timescales Jeremy Carroll
RE: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 5th Christopher Welty
preliminary agenda - Dec 19 telecon Jim Hendler
Re: owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Jim Hendler

Tuesday, 17 December 2002

ADMIN: regrets Dec 19 and Jan 2 Evan Wallace
ADMIN: Minutes Dec 12 Evan Wallace
5.17 again - Re: How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Jim Hendler
Re: How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Dan Connolly
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Jim Hendler
Re: How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Jim Hendler
Re: How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Dan Connolly
Re: How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Dan Connolly
owl:Ontology in abstract syntax Jeremy Carroll
How to close issue 5.17 - XML presentation syntax Jim Hendler
How to close issue 5.8 datatypes Jim Hendler
How to close issue 5.13 - internet media type for OWL Jim Hendler
OWL DL is very restrictive Jeremy Carroll
oneOf explicit dt values Jeremy Carroll
Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: Feature Synopsis document: a review Frank van Harmelen
Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics pat hayes
Re: editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc pat hayes

Monday, 16 December 2002

Re: editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc Jim Hendler
Re: editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Issue 5.17 XML presentation syntax for OWL Jeff Heflin
Re: editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc pat hayes
ADMIN: telecon dates through f2f Jim Hendler
Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics herman.ter.horst@philips.com
Re: editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Feature Synopsis document: a review herman.ter.horst@philips.com
Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics herman.ter.horst@philips.com

Sunday, 15 December 2002

TEST: latest owl testcases Jos De_Roo
editorial tweak to OWL semantics doc pat hayes

Friday, 13 December 2002

vizualizing webont chatlogs with SVG Libby Miller
WOWG: HUMO(U)R from our bloggers... Jim Hendler
datatypes part 3 Jeremy Carroll
Move OneOf to Owl Full (carried over from telecon) Jim Hendler
ADMIN: Revised Minutes Dec 5th Jeremy Carroll
Re: TEST: format of issue 5.6 - owl:imports Jos De_Roo

Thursday, 12 December 2002

RE: Guide: Tags added Smith, Michael K
Re: Guide: Tags added Dan Connolly
Guide: Tags added Smith, Michael K
Re: Abstentions on closure of internet media type issue Jos De_Roo
Re: Abstentions on closure of internet media type issue Dan Connolly
Re: TEST: format of issue 5.6 - owl:imports Jeremy Carroll
Abstentions on closure of internet media type issue Evan Wallace
Re: ISSUE 5.14 Closing Text Mike Dean
Re: owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth Deborah McGuinness
RE: GUIDE: vocabulary words in TOC, please Smith, Michael K
Owl Lite v. Owl DL - from heat light (was ... hasValue ...) Jim Hendler
Re: TEST: format of issue 5.6 - owl:imports Jos De_Roo
Re: ISSUE 5.14 Closing Text Jeff Heflin
proxy voting Dan Connolly
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Peter Crowther
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Peter Crowther
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
Regrets for 12-Dec, 19-Dec, 26-Dec, 2-Jan Jonathan Dale
RE: GUIDE: 5.9 malformed restrictions: "don't do that" Smith, Michael K
RE: ADMIN: Minutes Dec 5th Smith, Michael K
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Dan Connolly
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Peter Crowther
RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Peter Crowther
Vote on hasValue (was Re: owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth) Jim Hendler
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
Oops (Re: Review comments on OWL Semantics) Jeremy Carroll
Review comments on OWL Semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 - Unique names assumption Jos De_Roo
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jeremy Carroll
Re: owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth Ian Horrocks
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
Re: Issue 5.13 mediatypes: Proposal to CLOSE Mike Dean
Re: Issue 5.13 mediatypes: Proposal to CLOSE Jonathan Borden
Re: owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth Jim Hendler
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler

Wednesday, 11 December 2002

Re: owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth Deborah McGuinness
Re: Issue 5.17 XML presentation syntax for OWL Dan Connolly
owl lite starting to look like more trouble than it's worth Dan Connolly
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
SEM/TEST: "a" owl:differentFrom "b", no? Dan Connolly
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Frank van Harmelen
Re: Issue 5.13 mediatypes: Proposal to CLOSE Dan Connolly
GUIDE: 5.9 malformed restrictions: "don't do that" Dan Connolly
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jos De_Roo
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
oneOfDistinct, a proposal for 5.18 - Unique names assumption Dan Connolly
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
GUIDE: vocabulary words in TOC, please Dan Connolly
Re: datatypes part 3 Dan Connolly
Re: TEST: format of issue 5.6 - owl:imports Jeff Heflin
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
Re: ISSUE: justifications (postponed) Jim Hendler
Blank nodes in OWL DL, OWL Lite Jeremy Carroll
regrets for Dec. 12 telecon larry.eshelman@philips.com
datatypes part 3 Jeremy Carroll
ADMIN: Minutes Dec 5th Jeremy Carroll
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jeremy Carroll
Re: ADMIN: Agenda for December 12 telecon Jeremy Carroll
Re: Datatypes - chair's ruling on part 4 [was proposal to close issue 5.8 datatypes] Dan Connolly
Re: ISSUE: justifications (postponed) Dan Connolly
Guide: Current version Smith, Michael K
Jan ftf agenda thoughts? Dan Connolly
RE: OWL Lite semantics Marwan Sabbouh
ADMIN: Agenda for December 12 telecon Jim Hendler
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
Datatypes - chair's ruling on part 4 [was proposal to close issue 5.8 datatypes] Jim Hendler
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jos De_Roo

Tuesday, 10 December 2002

Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Frank van Harmelen
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jim Hendler
Re: OWL Lite semantics Deborah McGuinness
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Deborah McGuinness
Re: OWL Lite semantics Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: OWL Lite semantics Deborah McGuinness
Re: OWL Lite semantics Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
Re: Guide comments Bernard Horan
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
Re: OWL Lite semantics (fwd) Ian Horrocks
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes

Monday, 9 December 2002

Re: OWL Lite semantics Jos De_Roo
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Jim Hendler
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Ian Horrocks
Re: ISSUE 5.14 Closing Text Mike Dean
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
ISSUE 5.14 Closing Text Jeff Heflin
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
Re: OWL Lite semantics Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jim Hendler
Re: OWL Lite semantics Ian Horrocks
Re: OWL Lite semantics pat hayes
Re: SEM: rdfs:subPropertyOf cases Jos De_Roo

Sunday, 8 December 2002

Re: OWL Lite semantics Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: SEM: rdfs:subPropertyOf cases Peter F. Patel-Schneider
TEST: making use of EARL Jos De_Roo
Re: SEM: rdfs:subPropertyOf cases Jos De_Roo
SEM: rdfs:subPropertyOf cases Jos De_Roo

Saturday, 7 December 2002

ADMIN: Manchester face to face RSVPs Jim Hendler
Re: Timeline - editorial issues with docs - implementation Jim Hendler
Re: irc log for 5th December? Dan Brickley
irc log for 5th December? Jeremy Carroll

Friday, 6 December 2002

Issue 5.13 mediatypes: Proposal to CLOSE Jonathan Borden
Re: OWL Lite semantics Jim Hendler
RE: Sketch: reasoning conformance levels (was RE: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite) Jeremy Carroll
OWL Lite semantics Jeremy Carroll
Re: question about imports pat hayes
RE: Guide comments Smith, Michael K
Re: question about imports Jonathan Borden
Guide comments Bernard Horan
Re: ISSUE 5.14: Revised proposal to close ontology versioning Jos De_Roo
Timeline - editorial issues with docs - implementation Jeremy Carroll
Re: question about imports Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: question about imports pat hayes

Thursday, 5 December 2002

Re: question about imports Peter F. Patel-Schneider
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Smith, Michael K
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) pat hayes
Re: question about imports pat hayes
Re: question about imports Frank van Harmelen
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Smith, Michael K
Re: question about imports Peter F. Patel-Schneider
Re: Issue: Add hasValue to OWL Lite Deborah McGuinness
question about imports pat hayes
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) pat hayes
regrets for 5.12. ruediger.klein@daimlerchrysler.com
Regrets Thompson, Lynne R
ADMIN: Minutes from Nov 21 meeting Jim Hendler
Re: ISSUE 5.19 proposal to resolve Ian Horrocks
Potential and/or partial regrets for Dec 5. Lynn Andrea Stein
Regrets for Dec. 5th larry.eshelman@philips.com
Regrets Dec. 5 Masahiro Hori
Regrets dec. 5 Jerome Euzenat

Wednesday, 4 December 2002

Re: Potential regrets for Dec 5th Jim Hendler
TEST: owl:allDifferent Jos De_Roo
Potential regrets for Dec 5th Evan Wallace
Regrets for Dec 5th ( possible ) & 12th ( definite ) Stanton, John
Introduction: Sean Bechhofer Sean Bechhofer
Regrets for 5th Dec Jonathan Dale
ADMIN: Guests for January f2f - suggestions sought Jim Hendler
WOWG: agenda Dec 5 telecon Guus Schreiber
regrets Dec. 5 Frank van Harmelen

Tuesday, 3 December 2002

Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Peter F. Patel-Schneider
OWL Ontology for XML Infoset? Dan Brickley
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Smith, Michael K
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jim Hendler
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Massimo Marchiori
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Smith, Michael K
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jeff Heflin
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jeff Heflin
regrets Dec. 12 Leo Obrst
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jim Hendler
RE: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Smith, Michael K
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Dan Connolly
[Fwd: Re: ISSUE 5.14: Revised proposal to close ontology versioning] Jeff Heflin
Re: ISSUE 5.14: Revised proposal to close ontology versioning Jeff Heflin
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jeff Heflin
Re: LANG: Proposal to close ontology versioning (ISSUE 5.14) Jeff Heflin

Monday, 2 December 2002

Re: ISSUE 5.14: Revised proposal to close ontology versioning Dan Connolly
ISSUE 5.14: Revised proposal to close ontology versioning Jeff Heflin

Sunday, 1 December 2002

Re: LANG: need to CLOSE Issue 5.6 Imports as magic syntax Jos De_Roo

Last message date: Tuesday, 31 December 2002 22:27:45 UTC