Re: TAG document: SOAP HTTP GET binding available

If you will permit me, I have a few comments on the document.  For the
moment, I'll limit myself to section 1 and section 1.1.  Depending on the
reception of these comments, I may have more.

Section 1. Introduction

   If the desire is to bind a web service to HTTP GET, then arguably this
   is a web service binding not a SOAP binding.  In fact, the Web Service
   Description Language already includes a number of bindings including
   HTTP GET & POST Binding defined in section 4
   <>.  Section 3 of this document describes
   the SOAP binding, and section 5 describes a MIME binding.

   Perhaps this input could be reformulated as a delta to the existing WSDL

Section 1.1 Requirements

   "The mapping from SOAP HTTP POST Binding to HTTP GET and back shall be
   automatable.".  This concerns me a bit as HTTP GET is supposed to be
   limited to "safe" operations - see  In
   general, this determination is not automatable.  Also, the WSDL bindings
   for the various protocols contain a number of protocol specific elements
   that influence the mapping between the abstract definition of the sevice
   and the formulation of bits that flow across the wire.

- Sam Ruby

Received on Tuesday, 7 May 2002 13:13:52 UTC