- From: Doug Schepers <doug@schepers.cc>
- Date: Fri, 5 Nov 2004 17:04:44 -0500
- To: <www-svg@w3.org>
13.5 Time Manipulation Very cool feature, but a few comments. - The IDL is missing. - You did not give a range or type for the values. You refer to both '0' and '50%' as possible values. Must it have a percentage sign, unless it's value is '0'? Can you use floating point units, such as '0.5' to indicate '50%'? - You state that this can be used to slow down or reverse the playback speed of an element; can it also speed it up, using a value like '150%'? - It's unclear whether this works for both animation of 'normal' graphical elements ('circle', etc.) and for video playback? If it works for video, what are the constraints, as regards streaming and such? - In general, I would like to see attribute values presented in a manner similar to attribute names (with a different color, of course). Something like <span class="attribute-value">'50%'</span>. I think this would add to the readability. - The name for the 'speed' attribute is very general, and conflicts with a possible 'speed' attribute I'm proposing in my BAM Spec. To avoid this, I would recommend using a more specific name such as 'graphic-element-SMIL-animation-time-container-speed'. Regards- -Doug
Received on Friday, 5 November 2004 22:04:47 UTC