Re: [wbs] response to 'Approval of Evaluation Videos 1-4 and 5'

Hi Shawn,

Thank you for your comments. Some responses inline below:


On 12/02/2020 23:21, Shawn Henry via WBS Mailer wrote:
> All videos:
> [ED-low] I find the sound effects with the icons of “Essential for some,
> useful for all” a bit sharp.

I added this to the agenda for discussion today.


> Video 1:
> [ED-low] 1:47 throughout, a green checkmark makes me think good! and a red
> X makes me think bad. So when I see red and green boxes here, I assume the
> red are things that need to be addressed and the green are things that are
> good. So it’s a bit odd that the green things get included in
> “prioritize the issues you need to address first”. (I guess I missed
> this in previous reviews.:(

Indeed we missed that but it may be an easy change. Would the orange 
color #BB531B that we use elsewhere work better for you? Or just red?


> Video 4:
> [ED-low] 1:49 – geesh, this still looks like a piece of paper in a
> computer, instead of a web form. sign. no biggie, at least it’s in a
> computer.

To me, this is a better analogy for "report" than a form is. We can 
discuss this too, if needed (I know you've marked this as "ED-low").


> Video 3:
> [ED-low] 1:22-1:29 the tools are paper instead of online. I guess I missed
> that before. sigh. Oh well, no biggie.

This has been pretty much from the start, so indeed difficult to change 
now. To me these are specifications/reports of the tools to select from.


>> ---------------------------------
>> [NEW] Review and approval Video 5
> 
> 0:55 the outer icons get smaller for no reason. no biggie, it just caught
> my attention and was slightly distracting

Good catch, I've added that to the bug-list.


> 0:27 this version has the computer and the checklist disappearing. I
> envisioned the people displacing the checklist, and the computer staying.
> …/me checks the script… “As we hear ‘the user experience’, we pan
> to the left so that the check list and computer are no longer visible (they
> disappear to the right), and we see 4 people (each differently colored).”
> hum, either I missed that, or it changed.:-)

I believe this was discussed during the previous call or maybe even two 
calls. Sorry this change was not clear. I hope you like or can at least 
live with this animation (I know you've marked this as "ED-low").

Having said that, your comment made me aware that the camera should be 
moving left instead of right as in the current animation. It was a very 
hidden "Easter egg" for the concept of "shift-left". I will add this to 
the agenda to see if we want to get this changed.

Thanks,
   Shadi

-- 
Shadi Abou-Zahra - http://www.w3.org/People/shadi/
Accessibility Strategy and Technology Specialist
Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI)
World Wide Web Consortium (W3C)

Received on Friday, 14 February 2020 10:55:50 UTC