- From: Harvey Bingham <hbingham@acm.org>
- Date: Wed, 28 Jul 1999 23:52:57 -0400
- To: w3c-wai-ua@w3.org
>Date: Wed, 28 Jul 1999 16:31:53 -0400 (EDT) >From: Alan Cantor <acantor@oise.utoronto.ca> >X-Sender: acantor@tortoise >To: Harvey Bingham <hbingham@acm.org> >Subject: Re: Your keyboard mapping survey > >Hello Harvey, > >I am madly preparing to go away on holidays, so I will not have a chance >to give your message the attention it deserves until the end of August. My >most recent paper -- and not my last! -- on keyboard-only access is posted >on my web-site under publications. http://www.interlog.com/~acantor/csun1998.htm >I am already planning revisions, with >an emphasis that MouseKeys and other mouse emulators do not compensate for >the lack of a good keyboard interface. > >After quickly reading your message, I want to emphasize that keyboard >access is not only a matter of memorizing shortcuts. Keyboard access means >that you use the computer in different ways than you would with a mouse. >It's not about mouse equivalents -- although these can be useful -- but >about approaching what one does in a radically different way. My argument >is that any task you can imagine should be able to be done equally well >with a keyboard or a mouse. At the moment, short shrift is given to the >keyboard interface. But by the same token, the point and click interface >is horrendously overcomplicated. But that is scarcely noticed because most >users take their computing tools for granted, and never imagine that they >could be different. > >Have a pleasant summer. > >Alan > >Alan Cantor >Cantor + Associates >Workplace Accommodation Consultants >New e-mail address: acantor@interlog.com >http://www.interlog.com/~acantor >On Wed, 28 Jul 1999, Harvey Bingham wrote: > >> In WAI-UA we've been discussing the desirability of using operating system >> conventions as a starting point. Did your survey of 600 application- >> specific keyboard mappings and hot keys look at conflicts across OSs, >> such as MAC not having some keys that are on PCs? >> >> I have misplaced your survey paper. Is it available on-line? It would be >> useful for our work. If so, would you send it to >> >> w3c-wai-ua@w3.org >> >> Out of curiosity I summarize the shortcuts and/or keyboard commands found >> using help from within some of the applications on my desktop: >> Eudora (2 F#, 30 Ctrl+, arrows, enter,esc, pgup pgdn) >> WinZip (3 F[178], 4 Ctrl[ANOP], 16 Shift+letters, 4 Shift+arrow keys, >> Alt+F4) >> Quicken (F1, some state-dependent, Home and End 1 to 4 repetitions, >> 19 Ctrl+letter, 2 date or checknumber [+-], 5 dates (tmhyr), >> 3 Alt+, ', +, -, Shift+Tab, Shift+Ins, Shift+Del, Enter, 8 >> Ctrl+other) >> and some Microsoft apps: >> Windows 98 (F10, Ctrl+F4,?26 Alt+underlined letter in menu) >> Multiple Document Interface( F1, 4 Ctrl+[CXVZ], Alt+F4, >> Alt+spacebar, Alt+hyphen, Alt+tab, Shift+F10, Delete) >> Also undocumented Alt+shift+Tab >> Accessibility (if enabled: 5 bizarre patterns of repetitions, times, >> keys, some needing two hands) >> Dialog boxes (ESC, spacebar, toggle checkbox, Alt+underlined letter, >> Enter, Tab, Shift-Tab, Ctrl+Tab, Ctrl+Shift+Tab, Backspace, F4, F5) >> Desktop, My Computer, and Windows Explorer (Shift+insert CD Rom, >> Ctrl+drag file, Ctrl+Shift+drag file, Shift+Delete, 3 F[235], >> Ctrl+A, Alt+Enter, Alt+double-click >> My Computer and Windows Explorer (Shift+click close, Alt+Left Arrow, >> Alt+Right Arrow, Backspace) >> Windows Explorer (Left Arrow, Right Arrow, Num Lock+Minus sign, >> Num Lock+*, Num Lock+Plus sign, F6) >> Magnifier (6 Windows+) >> Photo Editor (keyboard commands: 11 Ctrl+) >> Internet Explorer (some state-dependent, F[1456], F11, >> 15 Ctrl+[ABCDEFHILNPSVWX], Esc, 4 Alt+arrows, Alt+Home, 4 nav >> arrows, Enter, PgUp, PgDn, Home, End, Tab Shift-Tab, >> Ctrl+Tab, Ctrl+Click, Ctrl+Enter, Shift+Ctrl+Tab) >> >> Regards/Harvey
Received on Wednesday, 28 July 1999 23:52:04 UTC