- From: R. Dolloff <averil@concentric.net>
- Date: Fri, 24 Apr 1998 00:02:23 -0500
- To: w3c-wai-ig@w3.org
- Cc: kynn-hwg@idyllmtn.com
Kynn Bartlett wrote: >For this reason, I will use LONGDESC -- even though no web >browsers yet use it -- and not use D-links. I'm all for the >idea, but I'm very against the D-link method. RD:: Just to clarify anything I've said which may have been misunderstood by anyone reading posts to these lists, I do NOT support placing little Ds all over the place, visibly or otherwise, and for many of the same reasons as Kynn stated. Further, I am not 100% convinced of the necessity for an attribute called LONGDESC (or whatever it's ultimately called), _as I now understand its purpose_. In my opinion, the _word_ "D-Link" can be used in the same place as any other navigation hyperlink, such as "Home," "About Our Company," etc...and can be used that way NOW. An attribute unsupported by browsers and invisible to anyone who does not read source code, is still subject to misinterpretation (as I so ably demonstrated myself at the beginning of this discussion's thread). A hyperlink, visible or heard to all, serves both the purpose intended AND promotes awareness of the need for accessibility. Additionally, it might possibly provide an extended service (information/training) to web audience members OR designers who might otherwise turn off "accessibility configurations" in their browsers. Once it's widely supported, maybe. But I'd still like to hear a better argument than I have to support its implementation. It should also be pointed out that no matter what methodology is ultimately considered "universal usage," the proof of the pudding will be in the descriptions on the description page itself as to whether or not thorough, therefore equal, translation has been made from inaccessible media to accessible. For that, there are no mechanical techniques, as the responsibility rests with the web author's insight and common sense. But it's good that we start somewhere, eh? <smile> Ree' Dolloff
Received on Friday, 24 April 1998 01:00:36 UTC