- From: L Robinson <dirk.samuel.robinson@gmail.com>
- Date: Wed, 8 Jan 2014 21:33:51 +0000
- To: EOWG <w3c-wai-eo@w3.org>
- Message-ID: <CAEN6yiKX3mvk3MSznP+NgG0GM3bzeLOg9AZfNBvbQ8us1MvGzQ@mail.gmail.com>
Dear Group i am trying to play catch up, with little or no knowledge of HTML 5, and unsure of what is happening in server side scripting. However, i have some observations, of how things seem to have changed over the past decade, or decade an a half: There seems to have been a huge shift form server side form verification, to client side "mechanisms", which may or may not include server calls. The most obvious example of such would be an Ajax calendar widget capable of letting one choose a real date from four decade limits, let us say. When it comes accessibility such a widget is a real non-starter. Arguably, three select boxes, one for month, one for date, and one for year, would be far preferable, with server side verification to reject February 30th. Autocomplete mechanisms also seem counterintuitive: it is expected that when i search on a search engine, that i am searching for the same things that others are, yet it would seem that the majority of the time when i am asked to select a country (and a finite list of options exists) i do not seem to encounter autocomplete, at a time when it would be at its most useful. As i said, i am largely ignorant of HTML 5. It appears to me that a very small number of <form> elements found in HTML 4, when used intelligently, are capable of driving any required interface, but all one seems to see these days is graphical submit buttons, widgets, Ajax objects, etc. Perhaps i am a fossil, although i would only wish to offer the humble opinion that things seem a little overdeveloped ... Yours faithfully, Lewis. *— Mr Robinson —* BA (hons) Oxon. 271 Liverpool Road London N1 1LX
Received on Wednesday, 8 January 2014 21:35:05 UTC