MINUTES of XSL WG telcon 2016-06-09

(Minutes taken by Luis and checked by MHK)

Meeting of the XSLT WG
Date:  Thursday 9th June 2016
Time: Stipulated times
Duration: 90 minutes

The XSLT Working Group met on Thursday, 9 June 2016 for 90 minutes. The meeting started at the usual START TIME and the group deliberated on the following issues:

Luis volunteered to take minutes.

Present: Michael Kay (chair), Abel, Michael Sp-McQ, Luis, Carine.

The previous minutes from 2nd of June were approved.

Review of Actions 

§§ Abel to send out emails on action (ACTION-2016-03-31-003:)

§§ ACTION 2016-06-02-003: (bug 29667) remains outstanding.

§§ ACTION 2016-06-02-001 MSMcQ apologized, and hopes to have it in by next week.



6: Options for what https://www.w3.org/TR/xslt Carines' action item email

§§ Left to Sharon as it was not expected to be discussed this week.

7. XSLT Draft

§§ This issue is to be discussed later.



8. Spec bugs

§§ 29690: the issue for this bug was marked as resolved as there was no objection to it. The editor was asked to look out for any interaction with bug number 29472 when applying this change.

§§ 29686: this issues was discussed, and marked as an action item for Mike to come up with a proposal for detailed rules and wording changes.

ACTION 2016-06-09-001: MK to produce detailed wording proposal to resolve bug 29686 along the lines suggested.

§§ 29675: this bug was raised by Abel, no difficulty about it, so it was marked as accepted. (Post meeting: changes now applied to the spec.)

§§ 29674: Mike believed he had fixed it. It was a duplication and should not have been in the agenda. It's been fixed.

§§ 29673: as for this bug, an n-dash or m-dash was adopted as a suggestion for this bug. This could be a better way of illustrating this information. Resolved.

§§ 29670: for this bug, Abel summarized where we are. Abel came up with what the spec currently allows. It was fully discussed, and marked as an action for Abel to raise an issue on dropping streamable global context item to replace 29670.

ACTION 2016-06-09-002 Abel to raise a new bug entry to replace 29670, proposing dropping of streamable global context items.

§§ 29669: done and should be closed as it was previously reviewed the week before and marked resolved and closed.

§§ 29667: it was discussed and Mike was to close it, and can be removed from the agenda next time.

§§ 29513: Still the subject of an outstanding actipn item Mike promises to get it done.

§§ 29472: This item is left open.

Additional Agenda Item

This issue and the email from Abel on 'Invocation variants for streaming and non-streaming in XSLT 3.0' were extensively discussed.

The group will come back to it and may have a general action to everyone to review it, and consider the impact on the spec.

ACTION 2016-06-09-003 on ALL to review Abel’s email at https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-xsl-wg/2016Jun/0005.html (Invocation Variants) and consider what changes to the specification might be needed as a result of this analysis.



Test bugs

Not discussed.

Received on Monday, 13 June 2016 17:01:28 UTC