- From: michael odling-smee <michael.odling-smee@xml-solutions.com>
- Date: Thu, 1 Nov 2012 17:33:27 +0000
- To: public-xformsusers@w3.org
- Message-ID: <CAJEDUV=91UmyX=rzzbXeYzG8cny4oroTZ7Tp8-0eqn4feYRFUA@mail.gmail.com>
All, I have two use-cases for form submission error handling/highlighting that I am not sure how to manage with vanilla XForms. *validation-error scenario 1* I recently posted this help request to the XSLTForms sourceforge page regarding highlighting a required field upon form submission: https://sourceforge.net/projects/xsltforms/forums/forum/878085/topic/6025530 In essence I am trying to emulate a common HTML form behaviour by highlighting fields where incorrect values have been provided or where a mandatory field has been left blank. When the field is invalid I can achieve this via the xforms-invalid event which then associates the :invalid css psuedo class (or .xforms-invalid in the case of XSLTForms) with the appropriate form elements. When a required field is left blank however no css class is associated with the element and although the form submission fails I cannot help the user easily identify which form element was the cause. With pure HTML forms it is fairly typical to highlight required fields that are empty after the user presses the submit button: this is the behaviour I am trying to recreate. Perhaps the addition of a new CSS class upon form submission would allow some control? Is this something that would be required in the XForms language, or would this be implementation specific? To test out the behaviour try submitting the form at http://www.forms4health.com/registration.xml a) Try putting in an invalid email address (e.g. fred) and press the book button - a global validation error is shown and the offending field is highlighted b) If you leave the field blank and press the "book" button - a global validation error is shown, but I currently cannot highlight the offending field *validation-error scenario 2* As an additional requirement (and this is probably less common), I want the user to provide at least one value for a form entry in an <xf:repeat/> section. At the moment the backend picks up this fault and sends an error message back, however it would be good if the form on the client side could do the same and (as above) highlight the offending field to the user. To try this out use the same form ( http://www.forms4health.com/registration.xml), put in a valid email address and leave the "booking reference" blank. Again a global validation error is provided but the offending field is not highlighted. Any thoughts? Michael
Received on Thursday, 1 November 2012 17:33:55 UTC