Re: Misc Comments - Part 2

I did not see any response to 6). and 7). below. Any comments ?

-Arun

Arun Gupta wrote:
> 
> 1). What additional interop does test1204 test for other than that 
> tested by test1202 and test1203 ?
> 
> 2). In test1205, if FaultTo address is "none" then no fault message 
> should be sent back. Moreover the message from A to B is a one-way 
> message, so even by that there should be no response sent back. I think 
> SOAP12-HTTP-In-Only-Fault does not fit here unless I'm missing something 
>  obvious.
> 
> Further, I'm trying to understand what WS-A feature interop is this 
> testcase testing ?
> 
> 4). There is no test for "Action Not Supported" fault. I thought at one 
> time we agreed that is the most common fault scenario (cant find 
> reference though). On a related point, I think test1240 should instead 
> be checking for "Action Not Supported" fault since that is more likely 
> to occur. A duplicate To or any other WS-A header in the SOAP message is 
> less likely to occur.
> 
> 5). test1133: Test description does not mention about ReplyTo containing 
> reference parameters but even then there is an XPath check. I think the 
> XPath check is correct as it will ensure that even though both ReplyTo 
> and FaultTo has reference parameters, only FaultTo refps are returned. 
> Further, the test description should be updated to reflect that.
> 
> 5). What interop feature is 1206 testing ?
> 
> 6). In test 1207, is the inconsistency between the number reference 
> parameters and metadata intentional ? I think we should try to keep the 
> test simple and just one of each (I dont care which one we choose).
> 
> 7). I thought the purpose of test1208 is to test all possible 
> extensiblity points. But no EPR extensiblity attributes are used ? For 
> example in the related message [1],
> 
> <wsa:ReplyTo>
> 
> could be replaced with
> 
> <wsa:ReplyTo extraMetadata="true">.
> 
> Similarly, there are no extensiblity attributes on wsa:Address. For 
> example,
> 
> <wsa:Address>
> 
> could be replaced with
> 
> <wsa:Address physical="true">
> 
> [1] 
> http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/addr/testsuite/documents/notify/soap12/message9.xml 
> 
> 
> Thanks,
> -Arun
> 

-- 
got Web Services ?
Download Java Web Services Developer Pack from
http://java.sun.com/webservices

Received on Tuesday, 17 January 2006 03:39:26 UTC