- From: Anders Rundgren <anders.rundgren@telia.com>
- Date: Sun, 3 Sep 2006 09:31:37 +0200
I know that this issue is a bit touchy among web purists but the fact is that the world is going from surfing to applications. The "wet dream" is actually to get the same functionality in the browser like in a "fat client". But it is very hard to create certain types of applications without having modal dialogs. AFAIK the existing alert() box is already modal (at least in MSIE) so modality is well established. That modal dialogs like featured in MSIE are not that much used is because there is no similar function in other browsers. You can to some extent "simulate" modality in Firefox but this simulation is [of course...] not supported by MSIE. The argument that tabbed browsing is incompatible with modality is something I don't buy into, it is an implementation issue. Exactly the same issues should apply to alert() BTW. Although AJAX may be great, it does in no way replace the need for having modal "transaction points". The net effect of ignoring legitimate needs of "legacy" app developers is forcing them into using a single browser, possibly also using non-web extensions like XAML. I think this consideration is more important than if a feature is absolutely "right" or "wrong". Sincerely Anders Rundgren
Received on Sunday, 3 September 2006 00:31:37 UTC